Carnifex Celebrate a Decade of Despair (2015)
Author: Primož Novak
Video: Primož Novak
Location: Gala Hala / Ljubljana / Slovenia
Concert date: 14.12.2015
Ticket price: 22€ / 25€
American deathcore band Carnifex have stretched their 10-year anniversary celebration into club shows too. This year the band played Metaldays for the first time ahead of the current tour. But a festival appearance alone doesn’t really reflect how popular they are, so it was time once again to win people over in a smaller room. This time it was even Gala Hala at Metelkova rather than Šiška, where they’ve already played a number of times.
Kicking off Saturday’s brutalization were Australia’s Boris the Blade, who tried to convince us with fast songs and breakdowns that they’re something special. But it quickly turned out that Boris the Blade are just one more deathcore band with nothing special about them. It all sounded pretty worn out, especially when the forced breakdowns came around. The rhythm section does have a few interesting parts. But the bigger problem was the vocalist, who tried to win people over with his “emotional” performance, at one point wandering down off the stage with the mic and singing his verses straight into the crowd’s faces. Boris the Blade clearly invest a lot in the show, but obviously not enough in the music.
San Francisco’s Fallujah stepped onto the Gala Hala stage for the third time and, of course, delighted once again. This time the sound was solid too, so you could actually make out the instruments. In their short set Fallujah played songs from both albums, plus the new track Abandon, which will appear on the new album due out in the first half of 2016. Fallujah are undoubtedly something special: the band presents extreme metal quite cleverly, bringing black metal touches and assorted keyboard extras into technical death metal, which makes the whole thing even sharper. With their second album The Flesh Prevails (review HERE) Fallujah showed that they’re progressive, unpredictable and brutal. Their unusual structures and rhythmic twists made it hard for the headbanging crowd to keep up with the music. Even though Fallujah’s set was fairly short, there was enough time to get swept up in the band’s atmospheric and brutal music, where the dynamic rhythms were matched by virtuosic soloing that flirts with today’s technical death metal. If Fallujah stick to their course, we can expect plenty more from them.
With Within the Ruins the soundscape shifted a bit. The band, promoting last year’s release Phenomena (review HERE), is technically skilled, but not to the same degree as Fallujah. Their songs are simpler and aimed more at a crowd that finds choruses easier to remember and can move to them a bit too. The breakdowns help with that, and luckily they’re not as conventional as in other deathcore bands, so you can talk about Within the Ruins as a band trying to show something new. Even more than the breakdowns, though, it’s the occasional syncopated riffs that stand out, reminding you of melodies from nineties video games. There’s not much to complain about in the performance itself: they’re clearly well rehearsed, the drummer shows plenty of skill live, and vocalist Tim Georgen does a nice job egging the crowd on to go wild. The only problem is that quite a few guitar parts were pre-recorded, which doesn’t give off much originality. An extra guitarist would probably have rounded out the whole picture.
Carnifex played, as always, with confidence and without compromise. In barely an hour they delivered a best-of from all five albums of their career. The songs were mostly fast, interrupted by the odd short breakdown. The band even promotes through its merch that they play strictly death metal, with slogans like “Defend death metal” or, simply and clichéd, “Death fuckin’ metal”. Carnifex obviously don’t want to be labeled as just deathcore, since that’s often seen as derogatory, and they probably also want to bring their music closer to a bigger audience, which they didn’t get at this show.
The band’s form itself is good. You couldn’t spot any slip-ups, Scott Lewis’s vocals are powerful, and the rhythm section is no slouch either. The band’s energy is more than up to par too, even though the two guitarists are a bit static at times. So Carnifex served up their death metal, which they tried to take to the next level on their latest album Die Without Hope (review HERE) by weaving in elements of black metal. There was certainly a push to progress, but nothing too earth-shattering. The crowd went wild the whole time, so despite the freezing cold outside it was nice and warm in the hall. As headliners, Carnifex get a little tiresome. They catch the Obituary syndrome, the same one thrash metal revival bands get. Things turn dry and predictable. There are no surprises anymore, everything’s cut from the same cloth. Not even the songs on eight-string guitars or the occasional solos helped. Maybe the openers showed too much and overshadowed Carnifex a little, who were merely average and nothing more.
All things considered, Carnifex showed at Gala Hala that they haven’t aged a day in ten years and that they’ve got plenty ahead of them, as long as they stick with it and, of course, keep playing smaller venues too.
Photo gallery

























