A Trick Of The Tail
Author: Peter Podbrežnik
Artist: Genesis
Label: Virgin Records
Released: 1976
Rating: 5/5
The brilliant Peter Gabriel left the band after the 1975 tour, right at the peak of their greatest creative stretch. The group’s future didn’t look too rosy to the remaining members, since someone as charismatic and creative as Gabriel simply couldn’t be replaced. After failed auditions for a new singer (a fair number of assorted oddballs showed up, dressed in weird costumes, desperately trying to imitate Gabriel’s stage antics, but they could neither sing nor play) the band decided that the new frontman would be none other than drummer Phil Collins, who had already shown his chops in the past with vocals on the ballads “For Absent Friends” (Nursery Cryme, 1971) and “More Fool Me” (Selling England By The Pound, 1973), as well as being the main backing vocalist.
Back then, before this album came out, most people saw this as a very risky move, even a rash one on the band’s part, since it wasn’t exactly common in rock for a lead singer (and one as charismatic as Gabriel, no less) to be replaced by the band’s own drummer. But Genesis pulled off the impossible, and “A Trick Of the Tail” is in many ways even their most mature record. Sure, a good chunk of Gabriel’s magical, dark, mysterious and romantic Victorian atmosphere vanished, along with his sarcastic vocals and lyrics (not to mention the stage shows), but with Collins at the helm the band sounds somehow more carefree and optimistic here than usual. On some tracks Collins’ voice strangely echoes Gabriel’s (e.g. “Squonk”, “Robbery, Assault and Battery”), while “Mad Man Moon” is a lovely showcase of his own particular vocal talents. Collins exceeded all expectations and proved to be the best possible replacement for Gabriel. Of course, he never managed to top Gabriel’s vocal and stage charisma, but both in the studio and on stage he established himself as an extremely emotional singer. As usual, the romance and mysticism of the album come mostly from keyboardist Tony Banks and guitarist Steve Hackett. On this very record, both delivered some of their finest moments. The harmony between them is truly remarkable, and often their instruments blend so perfectly that it’s sometimes hard to tell them apart. The rhythm section is more jazzy than ever before, thanks mostly to Collins, who, despite his new double duty, doesn’t skimp on his dynamic drumming this time either. Rutherford, meanwhile, plays his bass fluid and creative.
“Dance On the Volcano” is probably one of the best opening tracks in prog rock, period. The key moment for every fan comes right after the first minute, when Collins’ vocals kick in. He sings so well that it feels like Gabriel never left the band at all. It’s also the only track where Collins sounds truly angry, the way Gabriel could. Later his voice became more unique and quite different from Gabriel’s, but at that point it surely made most fans happy, the ones who were scared of how he’d handle the lead singer role. Calm and dramatic passages keep trading places, and the song is packed with an incredible number of such tempo shifts. The mood is close to that pastoral, mysterious atmosphere that marked most of the band’s earlier masterpieces. There’s no shortage of drama this time either. Seasoned, as it should be, with melodic choruses. Besides Collins, the other three are working wonders too. Banks is practically playing around with the Mellotron, organ and piano, while the ever-creative Hackett pours out inventive riffs like there’s a bet on. It’s often hard to tell Hackett’s and Banks’ parts apart on the record, they fit together so seamlessly. Collins’ drumming is just as masterful. Despite his double role as singer, he’s even gotten better.
“Entangled” has a gentle, very fragile central melody and an incredibly mystical mood, created mainly by the Mellotron and excellent vocal harmonies. The latter are among the best in the band’s history. There’s Mellotron aplenty here, and all lovers of this wonderful instrument will get their fill. Maestro Banks demonstrates some of his most original and breathtaking work on it. Hackett’s brilliant acoustic accompaniment, in perfect harmony with Banks’ keyboards, absolutely “rips”. Here the band kept its progressive, classic face, adding some classic acoustic Hackett solos and an extremely catchy Collins chorus into a proper acoustic labyrinth.
Next comes a direct segue into “Squonk”. It’s one of the best transitions into another song I’ve ever heard in rock. Gabriel’s spirit comes alive again here, both in Collins’ vocals and in the lyrics. It’s one of the most mystical mid-tempo songs ever.. It’s got everything the heart of every fan of the band could wish for. Banks’ keyboard passages, Hackett’s classic riff, Collins’ dynamic drumming, and I could go on. A song that leaves anyone who wrote the band off after Gabriel’s departure speechless.
“Mad Man Moon” is a typical Banks romantic semi-ballad. It’s built mainly on his keyboards. Banks first builds up the mood on piano, then focuses mostly on the Mellotron and, with the rest of the band backing him up, creates a wonderful composition. Here Collins first clearly shows the difference between his voice and Gabriel’s. Above all as a brilliant ballad singer. Something that always suited him down to the ground.
“Robbery, Assault and Battery” is the closest thing to one of Gabriel’s vocal grotesques (à la “Harold The Barrel”, “Get Em Out By Friday”, etc.), especially Collins’ singing style, which is mostly sarcastic and mischievous and built as monologues, which is exactly what Gabriel was known for. It also has a funny, swaying rhythm line. It’s by far the wittiest track on an album dominated mostly by romantic epics and (semi-)ballads.
“Ripples” is a composition of a completely different kind and maybe even the most beautiful song the band ever created, and they’ve made quite a few. An esoteric melody built on Hackett’s acoustic guitar and Banks’ Mellotron, followed by a gorgeous chorus that won’t leave your head anytime soon. Then comes a longer instrumental section featuring one of Banks’ best solos, accompanied by an excellent Hackett. “Ripples” is truly a majestic song and shows off Collins’ vocal quality as a ballad singer in the best possible way, as well as being one of the album’s most magical moments.
The title track, one of the band’s less typical compositions, even has a hint of a “Beatles” spirit (in the vocal harmonies) and an extremely sarcastic lyric, worthy of Gabriel himself, about a horned and tailed creature and its view of the human “creatures” who hunt it like a monster after it accidentally wanders into their (our) world. In the middle section the song briefly gets a “doo-wop” pop rhythm, which is unusual for the band. Without a doubt one of the band’s simpler compositions, not one of the classic epics they’re known for, but closer to classic rock and even pop. It also has a brilliant outro where the individual instruments weave in and out of each other.
And just like its brilliant opening, the record also has one of the best closers of any Genesis album with “Los Endos”. A wonderful instrumental that opens with an oriental motif on Mellotron and Collins’ drumming mastery, especially on the cymbals and other percussion. In the second part Hackett’s hard-rocking riff comes in, followed by a longer esoteric solo. As is the band’s tradition, many elements of earlier songs, which you could already hear at the start of the album, return toward the end of the track, which then builds up into “infinity”. You can even hear Collins’ vocals fading into the distance, which only improves the overall mood. During the outro he even sings two lines from the majestic “Supper’s Ready” (Foxtrot, 1972) – “There’s an angel standing in the sun” and “Free to get back home”, which can also be read as a symbolic farewell to Gabriel.
“A Trick Of the Tail” is one of the best records in the band’s history, and surprisingly, Gabriel’s departure is barely noticeable on it. The album shocked both critics and fans when it came out and was a commercial success in the UK and elsewhere around the world. After losing their main visionary, Genesis stepped into a new era without a hitch and made yet another brilliant album, with no shortage of the excellent epics the band was so prized for in the Gabriel era. The crystal-clear production is better than on any of the band’s previous albums. The album is also much more of a group effort than “The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway” (1974) was. It’s the first Genesis album where the members split the songwriting credits among themselves. You can feel that in the music itself, where there’s remarkable cohesion between the individual members, or rather their instruments. The quality of the individual songs is incredibly consistent, since all of them are played at an extremely high level while sounding completely different from each other. Meanwhile, the instrumental segments are once again top-notch. The band successfully kept its original sound while, after a very complex predecessor, making an album that was also commercially their most accessible since “Selling England By The Pound” (1973).
It’s downright incredible how successfully Collins managed to combine the roles of singer and drummer and carry the band forward. The band didn’t burden itself much with Gabriel’s legacy and moved on, even though “A Trick Of the Tail “is a “classic” album where the spirit of the band’s former singer and visionary is still somehow present. So Genesis kept everything that was best from before, added plenty of new goodies, and stepped very successfully into their next era.
Lineup
Phil Collins – vocals, drums, percussion
Steve Hackett – electric guitar, 12-string guitar
Mike Rutherford – bass guitar, 12-string guitar, bass pedals
Tony Banks – piano, synthesizer, organ, Mellotron, 12-string guitar, backing vocals
Production
David Hentschel and Genesis
Track list
1. Dance On A Volcano (5:53)
2. Entangled (6:28)
3. Squonk (6:27)
4. Mad Man Moon (7:35)
5. Robbery, Assault & Battery (6:15)
6. Ripples (8:03)
7. A Trick Of The Tail (4:34)
8. Los Endos (5:46)
Album length: 51:06