Gang Of Losers
Artist: Dears, The
Label: Bella Union Records
Release date: 2006
A Montreal sextet of perfectionists is back, this time with a slightly less “ambitious” third album. Less ambitious only because its predecessor “No Cities Left” from two years ago was a truly megalomaniacal marvel, packed with rich orchestral arrangements and (almost) flawless in its production. So one of the smarter moves when putting together a new album was the one they went for: simply scale a few things back, or not add them at all, while holding on to the quality of the songs, which, let’s be honest, is what matters most. The history of popular music has a pretty rich archive of “bad,” uncreative, low-quality records with great production! Of course the opposite is possible too, but the fact is that if a song doesn’t have that certain something, no amount of production can save it!
So with “Gang Of Losers,” The Dears have made a sonically fairly unburdened album, maybe even a bit more “down to earth” than the aforementioned “No Cities Left,” a critics’ darling, while keeping and building on everything that made them interesting and appealing back then.
It’s now clear the band doesn’t want to keep repeating the same old habits, and that’s the right call, but you can still hear that The Smiths left a big mark on their work. Singer Murray Lightburn in particular, maybe totally unintentionally, likes to slip into vocal patterns that are pure Morrissey. Interestingly, Murray is a Black Canadian, yet vocally he sounds unbelievably close to the British songbird. Take that as an observation rather than a criticism, because there’s no point equating them with anyone, which they’ve proven themselves with this wonderfully colorful, varied and pretty successful album.
Musically, they’ve set off on a journey through seemingly lighter, more optimistic-sounding melodies, and much of the credit for that goes to Valerie Jodoin-Keaton and Natalia Yanchak, who in the meantime has become Mrs. Murray Lightburn, handling backing vocals in the style of 50s and 60s girl groups. On top of that, there’s some new freshness, also thanks to the reduction of the orchestral parts mentioned earlier, which sounded much more like a kind of chamber pop. When it comes to the lyrics, though, it’s a bit harder to talk about lightness and carefree vibes. They mostly touch on social, everyday and somewhat less cheerful themes, which is already obvious from the song titles, e.g. Fear Made The World Go ‘Round, You And I Are A Gang Of Losers, Whites Only Party, Ballad Of Humankindness, I Fell Deep, and others. As a lyricist, Murray is clearly engaged and pretty critical of the current state of the political and economic world, but, at least for now, he still lacks that exceptional richness of language, metaphor or directness and boldness, and above all a more convincing delivery, which could lift him into the very top tier of today’s masters of the written and spoken word. Likewise, the music itself, while very listenable and accessible, though far from the countless times-tested formulas for success, is still not headstrong enough to earn its own separate chapter in the archive of popular music.
Lineup
Murray Lightburn – vocals, guitar
George Donoso – drums
Valerie Jodoin-Keaton – keyboards, whistle, vocals
Natalia Yanchak – keyboards, vocals
Patrick Krief – guitar
Martin Pelland – bass guitar
Track list
01. Sinthro
02. Ticket To Immortality
03. Death Or Life We Want You
04. Hate Then Love
05. There Goes My Outfit
06. Bandwagoneers
07. Fear Made The World Go ‘Round
08. You And I Are A Gang Of Losers
09. Whites Only Party
10. Ballad Of Humankindness
11. I Fell Deep
12. Find Our Way To Freedom
Album length: 48.07