Song Of Times

0 10

Author: Peter Podbrežnik

Artist: Starcastle
Label: Progrock Records
Released: 2007
Rating: 4/5

The return of American symphonic prog heavyweights Starcastle, almost 30 years after their last (rather ill-fated) studio album “Real To Reel” (1978), is a peculiar surprise and an event that hardly any fan of their music saw coming. Even though Starcastle were masters of gorgeous, melodic vocal harmonies, had a great rhythm section (especially true for the nimble-fingered bassist Gary Strater), and a tight chemistry between band members, while their mostly fantasy and philosophical lyrics (rather atypical for an American band) and mix of complex structures with high melody were also marked by a positive-minded approach, most prog rock fans remember them mainly for the fact that they came along long after Yes had already been around, and so saw them as a kind of American Yes clone. The main reason for this lies above all in the often downright startling similarity between the “angelic” vocals of their original singer Terry Tyrell (at one point he was also a founding member of AOR attraction REO Speedwagon) and of current singer Al Lewis, and the voice of Jon Anderson, who has always been known for his unique timbre. Personally, I never got hung up on this odd vocal resemblance or on the fact that Starcastle never brought anything particularly new or original to the world of prog rock, at least as long as they were writing good songs and didn’t lose their identity. So, despite two excellent releases like the debut “Starcastle” (1976) and “Fountains Of Light” (1977), and one less excellent but still solid one – “Citadel” (1977), they got overlooked by most of the prog community, and thanks to a not-too-successful attempt to adapt their sound to AOR trends on their last album, they stayed uninteresting to mainstream fans too, which is also what caused their breakup. They were mostly just unlucky to show up at the wrong time in the wrong place (during the rise of punk and in a relatively prog-uneducated USA), even though their countrymen Kansas were just then enjoying a big commercial breakthrough with “Leftoverture” (1976). With a bit better promotion things would surely have gone differently for “Starcastle” too, though maybe it’s even better this way than if they had made fools of themselves with pop like those aforementioned contemporaries did. The music landscape has changed radically since then. In the 90s, classic progressive rock got a new renaissance in the USA too (mostly thanks to bands like Spock’s Beard and Echolyn), which indirectly boosted interest in legendary, cult, long-forgotten bands like Starcastle. That finally gave these seasoned old cats the courage to regroup and start over, this time of course more out of a desire to make good music than to chase a commercial breakthrough, and the result is “Songs Of Times”.

A whole sea of different musicians plays on the album. In place of Tyrell (who does guest on the track “All For The Thunder”) there’s his vocal “twin” Al Lewis, and from the original members we get bassist Strater, guitarist Matt Stewart, keyboardist Herb Schildt and drummer Steve Tassler, while the new members are second guitarist Bruce Boots and drummer Jeff Koehnke. They’re also helped out by guitarist Mark McGee and additional keyboardists John O’Hara and Neal Robinson, who mainly handle the orchestral arrangements. An impressive number of musicians, but before hearing the album it still raises the question of whether, after all these years, “Songs Of Times” will manage to revitalize the band and keep it afloat as interesting enough even for generations that weren’t yet born when Starcastle broke up. The modern production surprisingly fits the band’s sonic identity very well and adds a much-needed youthful touch. Luckily, Starcastle have returned to their trademark symphonic-melodic style, with sweeping vocal harmonies and an extensive interweaving of keyboards and guitars. Most of the material is marked by tasteful symphonic arrangements, gorgeous vocal harmonies, fluidly built guitar solos, a good rhythm section and Lewis’s angelic voice. Many of the songs have a romantic, dreamy mood and a nostalgia for the days when life was simpler. Starcastle prove they’ve kept their signature approach of crafting complex, highly melodic and epic compositions.

The opening “Red Rain” already proves that Starcastle have come back in the right way and held on to their trademark sound, which they’ve upgraded with modern production. This shows most on the guitar, which now sounds even more energetic through most of the stretches. The song doesn’t really offer any standout moments and isn’t among their peaks, but it’s a lovely proof that they’re still worth listening to. The epic “Babylon” is one of the highlights of the whole album and impresses with its dreamy, majestic atmosphere as much as with its structure. It’s marked above all by Lewis’s vocals, the layered harmonies that come into their own in a superb chorus, good drum rolls and very strong guitar work. The central instrumental section is especially thrilling, with an excellent Strater bass solo proving he’s still made of the right stuff, plus Schildt’s atmospheric keyboards. “Babylon” is also nice proof that Starcastle are still capable of creating a masterpiece. The strikingly beautiful and atmospheric title track “Song Of Times”, with its gorgeous orchestral arrangements, acoustic guitar and angelic singing, evokes some Yes classic all by itself, but despite that melancholic symphonic quality and its majestic, serene mood reflecting boundless beauty, joy of life and sadness too, it has a different energy than the traditional “evergreen language” of Yes. “Islands” features a brilliant, jazz-spiced intro on bass, keyboards and guitar. Lewis’s vocals are once again straight from the heart, which is of course a rarity these days. The instrumental sections keep varying among themselves and, together with the vocal harmonies, create a dreamy atmosphere. “Faces Of Change” is a Starcastle classic that could easily have been on some 70s album, with its incredibly dreamy mood, super tasteful vocal harmonies and spacey keyboards. “Love Is The Only Place” can be a fine example to all the American prog rock bands who usually come off rather pathetic when they try to write love lyrics, while Starcastle sound extremely convincing and energetic. Besides a classic melodic chorus, the song also has some punchy sections as guitars and keyboards weave together. The closing guitar solo through a wah-wah effect is especially impressive. “Master Machine”, despite a fairly simple structure for them, is a very solid piece with an equal share of drama and epic feel. “All For The Thunder” is a thoroughly classic Starcastle song, partly thanks to original singer Terry Tyrell, combining complex shifts in time signature with exceptional melody driven by vocal harmonies, electrified guitar solos and tasteful keyboard textures. The guitar solo right after the main chorus is especially tasty, which is also the case this time. The closing “Children Believe” is one of the most interesting pieces on the album and probably the least typical for the band. What surprises most is Lewis switching up his vocal color, from protective, angelic to, by his standards, fairly raw, plus guitar parts that are at times extremely punchy, almost hard rock. Of course, it too is marked by an interplay of symphonic sweep, high melody, outstanding vocal harmonies and a wonderful mood.

“Song Of Times” is a highly successful comeback of classic Starcastle, one that exceeded my expectations and the Starcastle I’d kept in my memory, and proof that even after so much time they haven’t forgotten how to write wonderful compositions that keep their (overlooked) status as legends of American symphonic prog. Even though (as expected) they don’t bring anything particularly new to their musical expression, the album will delight all fans of melodic leanings in progressive rock, and give those who love classic 70s prog best and don’t care much for modern trends in the form of bands like The Mars Volta one more reason to “stay in the past”. If Starcastle carry on in a similar style or build on it, they could even become a fine example to much better known and more successful British peers who haven’t shown a studio sign of life in quite a while. Which band or bands I mean doesn’t need spelling out. I hope “Songs Of Times” will open the door for younger prog rock fans too to get to know their older work and so bring them closer to this unjustly overlooked cult band of American symphonic prog rock.

Lineup

Al Lewis – vocals (all tracks except 8), backing vocals (all tracks except 8), drums (9) and percussion (all tracks except 8), moog (9)
Matt Stewart – sustainer, electric sitar, acoustic and electric guitar (all tracks), backing vocals (1, 6, 7 & 8)
Gary Strater – electric & acoustic bass guitar and bass pedals (all tracks except 3), backing vocals (1, 2, 5, 6, 7 & 8), keyboards (3)
Herb Schildt – keyboards (1, 2, 6, 7 & 8)
Bruce Botts – guitar (1, 2, 4, 5, 7 & 9), backing vocals (5)
Steve Tassler – drums (6 & 8) percussion (1, 4 & 5), synthesizer (4), backing vocals (1, 2, 6 & 8)
John O’Hara – keyboards (3, 4 & 9)
Neal Robinson – keyboards (5, 6 & 8)
Steve Hagler – guitar (6), backing vocals (1, 4 & 7)
Terry Luttrell – vocals (8), backing vocals (7)
Mark McGee – guitar (1, 4 & 7)
Jeff Koehnke – drums (2 & 5)
Scott McKenzie – drums (1, 4 & 7)

Production

Gary Strater, Mark Rubel & Al Lewis

Tracklist

1. Red Season (5:28)
2. Babylon (9:24)
3. Song of Times (6:04)
4. Islands (4:59)
5. Faces of Change (4:56)
6. Love Is The Only Place (4:27)
7. Master Machine (4:24)
8. All For The Thunder (6:06)
9. Children Believe (6:21)

Album length: 52:09

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.

This website uses cookies to provide online services, advertising systems and functionality that we would not be able to offer without cookies. By visiting and using the website, you consent to the use of cookies. Accept Read more

Privacy & cookies