The Valley of Tears – The Ballads
Author: Peter Podbrežnik
Artist: Magnum
Label: SPV Records
Release: 2017
Running time: 53:50
Rating: 3/5
»The Valley of Tears« is a collection of ballads from the vault of English melodic art rockers Magnum. Some of the ballads were re-recorded, while the rest were ‘refreshed’ with remixes, so this release brings nothing special in the way of news and is, of course, aimed squarely at the most fervent Magnum devotees, the ones who don’t mind parting with their cash for yet another of the countless compilations with nothing musically new in the history of their favorite band. Over their colorful career Magnum have recorded plenty of fantastic ballads that are etched into the hearts of melodic rock fans for good. To be honest, the best ballads came back in the eighties, when the band was at the peak of its powers, though they’ve cut a few noteworthy pieces since then too, with a strongly melancholic streak that left a deeper mark.
Unlike most AOR bands, Magnum can boast that their ballads were never syrupy and, like most of their work, had a pronounced epic touch, which was mostly down to the two founding members: main songwriter, lyricist and guitarist Tony Clarkin and charismatic singer Bob Catley. The latter has the bad luck that his once superb voice has aged quite a bit over the years, and that’s probably the main reason Magnum didn’t dare re-record all the ballads on »The Valley of Tears«. Even with studio ‘polishing’ on the re-recorded ones, you can hear Bob struggling in places to get through the lyrics at a level even remotely comparable to the original versions.
It’s most obvious on the acoustic version of »Lonely Night« and the live version of »When the World Comes Down«, which means precisely the two most recognizable ballads, both pale shadows of the originals. Besides that, quite a few classic ballads from the ‘golden era’ are missing from this collection. You could say Magnum made some odd choices, since the lesser-known, ‘more modern’ ballads got priority. Instead of evergreens like »Two Hearts«, »The Last Dance«, »Need a Lot of Love« and »Start Taking Love«, they included some ballads written after 2000, while the welcome surprises are the inclusion of the »Rock Art« (1994) ballad »Back in Your Arms Again« and »Broken Wheel« from the often overlooked album »Sleepwalking« (1992). Catley still sings both in their new versions decently enough, thanks to the creature comforts of the studio, while live they’d probably come out quite differently, just like what happened with »When the World Comes Down«.
This collection of ballads from the distant and not-so-distant past, with nothing new on offer, will delight only the most devoted Magnum fans, while everyone else would do better to wait for their upcoming studio album, titled »Lost on the Road to Eternity«, which looks set to drop sometime in early 2018.
Lineup
Bob Catkey – vocals
Tony Clarkin – guitar, backing vocals
Mark Stanway – keyboards
Al Barrow – bass guitar
Harry James – drums, percussion
Production
Tony Clarkin
Tracklist
1. Dream About You (remastered)
2. Back in Your Arms Again (newly re-recorded)
3. The Valley of Tears (remixed, remastered)
4. Broken Wheel (newly re-recorded)
5. A Face in the Crowd (remixed, remastered)
6. Your Dreams Won’t Die (remastered)
7. Lonely Night (acoustic version, newly re-recorded)
8. The Last Frontier (remixed, remastered)
9. Putting Things In Place (remixed, remastered)
10. When The World Comes Down (new live version)