Marco Eneidi and Donald Robinson Fire Blanks at Gromka (2009)
Venue: Gromka, Metelkova, Ljubljana
Concert date: 16.06.2009
Attendance: 40
Metelkova keeps serving up interesting jazz gigs, and sometimes they hand us a heaping plate of jazz goodness, while other times they toss us just the leftovers, which fill you up but still leave you feeling like you got shortchanged. That last one is exactly what happened at the show by two American jazzers (one of them, Eneidi, currently lives in Austria), Marco Eneidi and Donald Robinson.
The duo is an intriguing combo of drummer and saxophonist, so I went in with pretty high hopes. Both are already well-respected names on their instruments, and that probably only ramped up the expectations of the small but knowledgeable crowd at Metelkova.
On the surface, the Robinson-Eneidi pairing looks pretty tempting. They bring avant-garde elements into their improvisations, and the playing is full of dissonance and sudden mood swings. But there’s no backbone, no real melodic foundation for the duo to lean on – the music just hangs in the air, wingless, and you keep expecting the whole thing to come crashing down. Well, maybe that image is a bit off, since for it all to come crashing down, the duo would first have to build something. And they don’t. They lay their bricks only in the vertical direction, forgetting about height, so the music sounds almost constantly two-dimensional.
Even though the duo didn’t show anything earth-shattering, the vibe at Metelkova was classic laid-back jazz (some people were determined to be more laid-back than others), and the performers came across the same way. Contact with the audience was minimal, stage presence negligible… Fine, you don’t expect that from a jazz gig anyway, but a bit more energy wouldn’t have hurt. I can’t tell whether it was simply being lost in the music or something else.
Technically, there’s nothing to fault the duo for. Both are accomplished musicians, especially Robinson on drums, who tried to inject plenty of liveliness into the performance by using all sorts of drumsticks and different playing techniques. But again, all of that falls flat without a melodic backdrop. Eneidi had similar problems – he’s clearly a first-rate musician, but sadly his technique is all that’s impressive. The two guys obviously made an effort for the crowd and put a lot of work and sweat into the show, but the gig reminded me that some musicians should stick to being sidemen and session players, because they just don’t have the knack for their own creations.
For me, the show was nothing more than aimless wandering through jazz notes. Sure, it was improvisational jazz, but even in those circles you can find far more interesting stuff, the kind that makes you think the musicians on stage have really experienced some kind of revelation. With Eneidi and Robinson, there was no such danger – it was just a random search for notes that sounded disconnected and uninspired. In the end, I have to say that to each ear its own painter (or Mahler), and my take is extremely subjective. Free improvisational jazz just isn’t my cup of tea, even though I can enjoy it (when it’s done well). So for me personally, the show was a swing and a miss, but maybe someone else can find some more encouraging words.
Photos: Rok Podgrajšek
Photo Gallery









