The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway

0 10

Author: Peter Podbrežnik

Artist: Genesis
Label: Virgin Records
Released: 1974
Rating: 5/5

A legendary double concept album that splits Genesis fans into those who hail it as the alpha and omega of all Genesis records and those who just can’t make sense of it, much like fans of Yes (Tales From Topographic Oceans, 1973), Pink Floyd (The Wall, 1979) or Jethro Tull (A Passion Play, 1973). But both camps surely have to agree that the band with Peter Gabriel hit its creative peak here and that there was simply nowhere left to go, musically or artistically. In fact, after the inimitable masterpiece “Selling England By the Pound” (1973), the band went right over the edge this time. Genesis found a simple but brilliant recipe for topping their greatest masterpiece to date – make a completely different record, with a totally different musical look and concept. It’s a recipe that few bands dare to try (then or now), since after their “creative peak” they usually attempt to imitate their most successful album (and, as everyone knows, more or less fail).

A double concept album with a surreal story about a poor Puerto Rican kid named Rael, who comes to New York looking for his lost brother, then unexpectedly travels through parallel fantasy worlds, mostly dark ones, filled with monsters and apparitions, to save his brother, who got trapped in one of those dimensions, is phenomenal, both musically and conceptually. The concept alone proves what a genius Gabriel was and how far ahead of his time he was. The story smells like a forerunner of modern sci-fi concepts about parallel worlds, or two worlds completely different from each other (The Matrix, Constantine and the like). Sadly, this was also when the rift between Gabriel’s genius and the rest of the band started to deepen, since most of them didn’t take well to his unusual concept, let alone understand it. He even wanted to make a film of it with director William Friedkin (“The Excorcist”), but unfortunately that project never came to anything. Rael’s encounters with apparitions are the subject of tracks like “Colony Of Slippermen”, “Lamia”, “The Carpet Crawlers” and so on. Many of the songs are also direct references to forbidden sex in a controlled society. Musically, this album is like nothing the band did before or after, which makes it a one-of-a-kind, unrepeatable artistic achievement. If I had to find a comparison, it reminds me most of Gabriel’s later solo work. The title track, “The Carpet Crawlers”, “In the Cage”, “Back In NYC” and “Riding the Scree” became a beloved part of the live shows and were played long after Gabriel left the band.

Personal problems (a difficult childbirth for his wife) also fed the growing rift between Gabriel and the other members during the recording of this record. For the first time, Gabriel didn’t contribute any musical ideas, only lyrics, while the rest of the band wrote the music completely separately from him. Banks in particular wasn’t too thrilled about Gabriel’s concept and his “isolation”. Still, in the end they managed to pull off an incredible masterpiece with plenty of varied songs that flow straight into one another and tell the story of Rael’s fantastic journeys.

Here’s a short synopsis of this surreal story for anyone curious about the background of the strangest concept in rock history: Rael, a poor Puerto Rican lad, is strolling down Broadway one evening, coming home from a grueling day as a graffiti artist, when a lamb suddenly appears in front of him and lies down before him. Rael bends over it and suddenly finds himself engulfed by a “wall of death”, turned into a “fly” on a “windshield” that carries him off to who knows where. Then his surreal journey into other dimensions begins. In one of them he suddenly spots his brother working in a factory that produces lifeless packages of strange, humanoid shapes. Meanwhile he suddenly finds himself trapped in a cage of his own memories, then falls through the “stomach” of memories and ends up in the company of a colony of carpeted, crawling apparitions. Rael manages to escape and suddenly finds himself in a room with 32 doors, only one of which leads out. The blind Lilywhite Lilth promises to lead him out by following the trail of a breeze, but instead takes him somewhere else entirely and leaves him in a waiting room. There he runs into the lamias. They’re a trio of snake “babes” who lure him into their pool full of pink water for a “topless” massage. But suddenly everything goes wrong when the lamias start nibbling at Rael and then shrivel up. In desperation, Rael eats them. After finding his tracks again, he falls into a colony of lewd Slippermen. It’s a vile pack of disgusting hedonists, given over to nothing but pleasures of the flesh. He suddenly spots his brother again, who has already become one of them, and it soon turns out that the lamias have turned Rael into one of them too. The only cure is castration at the hands of the wicked Doctor Dyper. After the doctor’s visit, Rael and the other Slippermen are forced to carry their “pouches” in a yellow plastic tube hanging around their necks. When a raven swoops down and steals Rael’s strange necklace, he chases after it, but the raven drops the necklace into a ravine. Rael slides down the rapids to the bottom of the ravine, where he (once again) sees his brother, desperately trying to keep his head above the raging current. Rael saves him, only to discover in the end that his brother is…him!

What does it all mean? Everyone can of course interpret this very strange Gabriel story in their own way (it’s also printed in the album booklet, by the way). My personal read of the story’s message is that “Lamb” is really a metaphor for Rael’s spiritual journey, or personal rebirth, through various personal “hells” (represented by the dimensions full of apparitions) to final redemption. By discovering “his brother” at the end, who is really himself, he finally discovers his “own self”, and that’s the end of his “hellish” journey. The lamb has always been a symbol of purity, and when the poor immigrant Rael finds it in New York (a metaphor for modern Babylon, i.e. a symbol of impurity and corruption), it leads him through the hellish worlds of his delusions so that he can reach his own redemption and self-knowledge in the end.

From a musical standpoint, this is a unique record. The songs on “Lamb” are mostly shorter, there are fewer epics, which had been one of the band’s main trademarks until then, and more shorter, more avant-garde pieces. The album is full of musical ideas the band never used before or after. There are some quite avant-garde creations here that you wouldn’t normally associate with Genesis. There’s much less of Tony Banks’ baroque keyboard sound, though he, along with Gabriel, once again takes up a lot of space on most of the band’s songs. Even the sound itself is completely different this time from anything before.

The opening title track is an ultra-melodic, compact and striking song with all the makings of a hit single (à la “I Know What I Like (In Your Wardrobe)” from the previous record), and among fans it’s still one of their most beloved songs today. “Fly On A Windshield” is a dramatic piece that doesn’t skimp on esoteric keyboards. “Broadway Melody Of 1974” is a very short melody on guitar and a curtain of sound, basically just a short overture to the next song. “Cucko Cuckoon” is a short, enigmatic and endearing little number built on mellotron, flute and Gabriel’s charismatic vocals. It’s a classic band move, calming the mood before the drama. The real masterpiece follows in the epic “In the Cage”, undoubtedly one of the peaks of the whole record and a song the band loved to play live for many years afterwards. It’s one of the most dramatic compositions on the record, with Gabriel’s downright claustrophobic vocals and a “deranged” rhythm line (though Collins doesn’t get as much room to maneuver on this album as on the last one, his even more technically adventurous drumming still stands out here). The central melody keeps the song from sounding too gloomy. Then comes another tasteful Hackett solo. The harmony between him and Banks’ organ in the middle section is excellent and represents exactly what’s most recognizable about the band. “In the Cage” is thus one of the few epics on “Lamb”, and even that one is something totally different from any epic before it. Next up is the interesting “The Grand Parade Of Lifeless Packaging”, one of the strangest and even most bizarre pieces on the record. But also, of course, wonderfully witty. As such it’s very welcome, since it calms the tense mood of the previous composition a bit. Gabriel’s satirical vocals and the bizarre lyrics about human packages being produced in a factory by Rael’s brother really don’t leave anyone cold. The great Brian Eno (ex-Roxy Music) appears here as a special guest, and his soundscapes add a lot to the atmosphere, but above all he used effects to considerably warp Gabriel’s vocals here.. Then comes “Back In NYC”, a composition with all the makings of a Genesis hit and, frankly, it even reminds me a little of some of the early work from Gabriel’s solo career. Gabriel’s vocals are put through effects again in the middle section. The song has everything a Genesis fan could wish for. A great chorus, Hackett’s wonderfully inventive riff and excellent solo, Banks’ esoteric keyboards, the jazzy Collins-Rutherford rhythm line and a “switched-off” Gabriel. Plus a short, fun part that reminds me a little of a tune from some Super Mario game. “Hairless Heart” is another shorter instrumental composition of a completely different kind. Here Banks shines in all the grandeur of his mellotron drama. A piece that would be perfect for some epic film. And then comes the funniest song on the whole record, “Counting Out Time”, which is wonderfully witty and as endearing as few songs in the band’s history. No wonder Gabriel is exceptionally playful here and can get plenty of people laughing. The song also has a great “metal” Hackett riff. Next is the dreamy, epic “Carpet Crawlers” with its “goosebump-raising” vocal lines between Gabriel and Collins and esoteric keyboards. One of the most popular and best-known songs from this album, it was also a successful single, which is no surprise with its melodic vocal harmonies and splendid chorus that won’t leave your ears anytime soon. The song also matters because in 1999 the band briefly got back together in its “classic lineup” and recorded a new version of it, which means it held special meaning for them. “The Chamber Of 32 Doors” is stylistically the closest thing to the earlier records, and it really works thanks to Gabriel’s sarcastic lines “I rather trust a country men than a town man” and “I rather trust a man who works with his hands”. The lyrics themselves are among the better ones on the record. And then there’s the deeply sad Gabriel with lines like “I am so alone with my fear, with everything I fear…”, which capture Rael’s lostness as he can’t find the right door to save him from the other dimension, or his personal “hell”, and lead him onto the right path.

The second part, even more experimental and avant-garde than the first, opens with the hyper-melodic “Lilywhite Lilth”, packed with layered harmonies and mellotron. Gabriel’s voice is once again charged with optimism, since Rael has finally found a hope that could lead him onto the right path. Next comes one of the band’s most avant-garde creations, “The Waiting Room”. With its recorded sounds of “shattering glasses” and “explosions” on Banks’ synthesizer (Eno probably had a hand in it too) and its horrifying atmosphere, it’s a song that isn’t for everyone, since it’s probably the most avant-garde piece in the band’s history. It sounds a little wicked. In the last section Rutherford’s bass takes up quite a bit of space. “Ayway” is another song with a “sad” Gabriel and an extremely dramatic atmosphere; a true closing cataclysm. “The Supernatural Anaesthetist” is Hackett’s “star” moment on the record, with a brilliant solo running practically through the whole song, one of his best with the band, period. “The Lamia” is another of the few songs that, in mood, slightly recalls the band’s earlier albums, or their early days. A melancholic Gabriel and an epic atmosphere intertwine over bizarre lyrics about three snake maidens who hypocritically lure Rael into a pool for a massage, where they try to devour him, but he fights back and pays them back “tit for tat”. “Silent Sorrow In Empty Boats”, with its excellent Eno sophistication, is almost the transcendental moment of the record. “Colony Of Slippermen (The Arrival/A Visit To The Doktor/Raven”)” opens with creepy sounds that make it easy to picture shriveled, morally annihilated apparitions lurking for everything “beautiful and bright”. It’s one of the most varied songs on the record. The intro, “The Arrival”, with its eerie sounds and the apparitions’ mumblings, gives no hint that this is yet another majestic epic. Next comes the excellent “A Visit To The Doktor”, as Rael heads off for castration at the hands of the wicked Doctor Dyper. This part contains some of Gabriel’s most bizarre lines, but has a superb musical backdrop. The last part, “Raven”, is the best, since it contains all the best elements of the band. “Ravine” is another short instrumental full of sound curtains that brilliantly conjures up the atmosphere of a gorge with raging rapids rushing through it and a cold wind blowing. “The Light Dies Down On Broadway” is the only song on the album whose lyrics weren’t written by Gabriel but by Banks and Rutherford. It’s a slower, more dramatic and more mystical reprise of the title track. It sounds pretty “spacey”. “Riding The Scree” is another great showcase of Banks’ mastery and Gabriel’s vocal acting, and one of the best songs on the album. “In The Rapids” is a true elegy, that is, almost a ballad. The album closes with “It”, which opens with a cataclysmic siren sound, followed by a “deranged” rhythm line, a Gabriel fully immersed in the role and a monumental Hackett riff (personally my favorite of his on the record). The chorus is phenomenal and one of the best the band ever came up with. It honestly surprises me that this song didn’t become a hit, or that it stayed so widely overlooked. It’s the best possible ending to the record and one of my favorite songs on the album. When Rael finally discovers his essence, he becomes aware of himself and frees himself from his long wandering in metaphysical worlds (that is, an aimless life) where he doesn’t belong. A bright and positive ending to a record that is otherwise pretty dark in mood. That’s it. Pure revelation!

Peter Gabriel, the soul of Genesis, left the band after this record and shocked most of the fans. It also marked the start of his very successful solo career, while for Genesis it meant the end of their most fertile period, the end of the “classic” era and a gradual shift toward more compact songs. The production of the album is brilliant even for its time, and the reissue reached an even higher standard. Musically, the band hit the greatest artistic peak of their career with this record. That’s exactly the main reason why “Lamb” is the most majestic and most mature album in the band’s history. It’s the summit of everything Genesis ever created. “The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway” is an album that serious lovers of good music simply have to own, not to mention fans of progressive rock.

Lineup

Peter Gabriel – vocals, flute
Tony Banks – keyboards
Steve Hackett – electric guitar, nylon guitar
Mike Rutherford – bass guitar, 12-string guitar
Phil Collins – drums, percussion, backing vocals

Production

John Burns and Genesis

Track list

CD 1 running time: 45:34
1. The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway (4:50)
2. Fly on a Windshield (4:23)
3. Broadway Melody of 1974 (0:33)
4. Cuckoo Cocoon (2:11)
5. In the Cage (8:15)
6. The Grand Parade of Lifeless Packaging (2:45)
7. Back in N.Y.C. (5:42)
8. Hairless Heart (2:13)
9. Counting Out Time (3:42)
10. The Carpet Crawlers (5:15)
11. The Chamber of 32 Doors (5:40)

CD 2 running time: 48:49
1. Lillywhite Lilith (2:42)
2. The Waiting Room (5:24)
3. Anyway (3:07)
4. The Supernatural Anaesthetist (2:59)
5. The Lamia (6:57)
6. Silent Sorrow in Empty Boats (3:07)
7. Colony of Slippermen (8:13)
a) The Arrival
b) A Visit to the Doktor
c) Raven
8. Ravine (2:04)
9. The Light Dies Down on Broadway (3:32)
10. Riding the Scree (3:57)
11. In the Rapids (2:26)
12. It. (4:15)

Album running time: 94:23

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.

This website uses cookies to provide online services, advertising systems and functionality that we would not be able to offer without cookies. By visiting and using the website, you consent to the use of cookies. Accept Read more

Privacy & cookies