Selling England By The Pound
Author: Peter Podbrežnik
Artist: Genesis
Label: Virgin Records
Release: 1973
Rating: 5/5
No doubt about it, this is the record where Genesis reached the creative summit of their “classic” era, and the one that set most of the standards for today’s symphonic and neo-progressive rock. It’s also, without question, one of the best rock albums ever made and one of the greatest musical achievements of the 20th century. The record is such a perfection of music and artistry that any review pretty much embarrasses itself next to it. For me it’s easily one of the five best rock albums I’ve ever heard. It’s hard to believe the band was putting out a better record every single year back then. As they matured musically and personally, their music grew right along with them. “Foxtrot” (1972) was the record that won them wider attention in the music world, but “Selling England By The Pound” wrote them into the books of the immortals for good. It’s also the commercial peak of the Gabriel era, and the album hit number 3 on the UK albums chart.
Sure, the brilliant singer, flutist, dramatist and actor Peter Gabriel is without a doubt the main driving force behind the band’s artistic development in its early years, and once again the central “star” of the record, but the contributions of the other members are anything but negligible. Every musician is at the top of their game here, and you can’t feel any one of them dominating. The band is equal in terms of what each member brings, and that’s one of the hallmarks of this period. From piano virtuoso Tony Banks, anything less than a flawless orchestral high point on organ, Mellotron and piano would have been a surprise. This is also the first Genesis album where he used a synthesizer. Steve Hackett is a one-of-a-kind talent and a superb guitarist who brought plenty of innovations to guitar playing. One of the best drummers in rock and jazz (or both at once), I’d say of all time, Phil Collins is as great as ever, especially with his colorful use of cymbals. His vocal contribution matters too. Mike Rutherford, bassist and occasional guitarist, who always loved reaching for the 12-string guitar and bass pedals, is another versatile player who was part of one of the best rhythm sections of the day. Gabriel’s lyrics, singing and flute playing hit their peak.
Let me say that “Selling England By the Pound” is a half-concept album about the decline of modern Great Britain, or rather the British Empire, and the songs flow into one another (which is typical of most concept albums). A “Victorian” conceptual spirit hangs over the whole record. In the lyrics, Gabriel finally settles scores with British class society and its fake morality. The album is packed with epics as well as shorter songs, all built on complex musical structures with loads of melody and virtuosity from the individual members. In short, everything that’s best about this band is here. And cranked up to the 10th power! Even the production is phenomenal for the time. Do I really still need to introduce such a great record in more detail?
“Dancing With the Moonlit Knight”, one of the best opening tracks in prog rock, kicks the album off on a high note, as is the band’s tradition. The song portrays the material and spiritual decline of the British Empire, which is also what the album title is about, and it gets a mention in this song. A calm intro is followed by a melodic chorus and Gabriel’s dramatic, fully immersed and ever-shifting vocals. Then the Collins-Rutherford rhythm duo soon carries us off to “prog heaven.” Hackett uses the then-revolutionary finger “tapping,” an invention often credited to him. And maestro Banks on organ and Mellotron weaves that mystical bond which, along with Gabriel’s voice, is the main carrier of the band’s musical identity.
The song flows straight into the excellent “I Know What I Like (In Your Wardrobe)”. When it came out, it gave them their first hit on the UK charts and put them on the radar of casual listeners too. The lyrics are wonderfully witty and sarcastic, about the total apathy of British aristocratic youth, who aren’t willing to give up their aimless life built on an “everlasting moment of pleasure.” It has a brilliant melodic chorus (where Collins’ backing vocals come through nicely) that won’t leave your ears anytime soon. “I Know What I Like (In Your Wardrobe)” showed what huge hit potential this band always had, even though until then they were known almost exclusively for longer, complex compositions. Despite its apparent simplicity and catchiness, the song still contains plenty of musical variety. It’s the first of many hits the band produced over its long career, and of course one of the classics of prog rock.
“Firth Of Fifth” is a gorgeous epic and a textbook case of perfect spontaneity between the individual musicians. It opens with Banks racing across the piano. The whole song gives off a feeling of “enlightenment,” and with its atmosphere in the middle section it even sounds somehow “Yes-like.” In terms of mood, it’s one of the brightest and most optimistic songs the band ever did. The last verse especially, “the sands of time were eroded by the river of constant change,” sounds like an act of final enlightenment, although I’m almost sure it’s just part of one of Gabriel’s concepts about social change. Still, the line sounds like the core of this band’s philosophy. Eternal change, always moving forward in music. Of course it’s very mystical and dramatic, so it has both of the band’s trademarks. In the lyrics Gabriel mentions sirens and Neptune, which are of course metaphors. The most beautiful part comes in the second half of the song, with Hackett’s gorgeous solo. One of the best solos from this guitarist I’ve ever heard. And of course the ending doesn’t lack Banks’ esoteric Mellotron and a synth solo. It’s one of the best epics in the band’s history.
“More Fool Me” is a shorter ballad sung by drummer Phil Collins (who had already tried himself in this role on the ballad “For Absent Friends” (Nursery Cryme, 1971)), and it calms down the drama that dominates most of the record at just the right spot. You could already call it one of Collins’ first “balladesques,” which hint at his later work with the band and the career that of course needs no introduction. It’s sung from the heart, with excellent backing vocals and acoustic guitar accompaniment.
“The Battle Of Epping Forest” is a tale of a clash between two street gangs of the day and another excellent epic. It’s really another brilliant Gabriel metaphor, about how the lower classes of Britain these days would rather beat each other up, since they can no longer serve the expansion of the former empire. The rhythm in the intro is deliberately a little militaristic. After that come all the best ingredients of Genesis’ music. Of course Gabriel’s vocal mastery and acrobatics are back too, including some short narration and playing different characters. Some would call it the satirical expression of the lyrics. In this he really had no equal. The epic ends in a completely different place than where it started, and it’s among the band’s most complex compositions, and there were quite a few of those.
“After the Ordeal” has a medieval, mystical intro on flute, guitar and piano. It might even be the best instrumental they ever made. Tony Banks and Steve Hackett shine here again. The song is among the finest showcases of Banks’ orchestral mastery. It truly sounds like it comes from some other, long-forgotten era.
“The Cinema Show” is without a doubt one of the album’s peaks (and there are quite a few) and, along with “The Musical Box” (Nursery Cryme, 1971), still the favorite song among the band’s fans. Hackett’s solo in the middle of the track is pure classic. So is Collins’ drumming. The multi-part vocal harmonies throughout are unbelievable. Gabriel is obviously poking fun again at English fake morality and forbidden love. It’s a farce on a modern Romeo and Juliet, who “took matters into their own hands,” yet it still sounds romantic. I find the part of the lyrics where Gabriel mentions a figure from Greek mythology, the seer Tiresias, especially interesting. According to legend, he was punished by the gods several times for his audacity: turned into a woman, then back into a man, and finally blinded, yet he kept his gift of prophecy even after his physical death. That’s what these lines say: “Once a man- like the sea I raged. Once a woman- like the earth I craved…There is in fact more earth than sea.” This is also the moment when the melodic transition kicks in and the song takes on an “enlightened” aura. Flute passages, Mellotron and multi-part vocals create a proper Celtic atmosphere. Everything best about Genesis is captured in this song.
“Aisle Of Plenty” closes the album. It’s a short bit of Gabriel’s satirical mannerism that wraps up the record both sadly and wittily. Once again you hear the melody and main riff from “Dancing With the Moonlit Knight,” which build toward “eternity” under a curtain of Mellotron. No, Peter Gabriel is surely not the kind of musician the Queen would have dared invite to her coronation anniversary or to play on top of Buckingham Palace. When it comes to criticizing the fake morality of British class society, I think only Ian Anderson (Jethro Tull), a Scot, can match him.
One of the best records in rock, period. I simply can’t find enough words of praise. Hardly anyone back then expected the band to follow “Foxtrot” (1972) with an even more ambitious record, one that marks the definitive artistic peak of the era with Peter Gabriel. “Selling England By the Pound” is a classic and a prog rock masterpiece that changed the lives of most people who love good music. It was this very record that introduced me to the wonderful world of Genesis, so it means something extra special to me. Still, I personally find it hard to decide whether this is really their best record or the one that came right after it, the strangest concept album of all time. After all, who would even dare think, with a record like “Selling England By the Pound,” that the band was capable of taking one more, final step in its musical development?
Lineup
Peter Gabriel – vocals, percussion, flute, oboe
Tony Banks – keyboards, 12-string guitar
Steve Hackett – electric guitar, nylon guitar
Mike Rutherford – bass guitar, 12-string guitar, electric sitar
Phil Collins – drums, percussion, backing vocals, vocals(3)
Production
Genesis, John Burns
Track list
1. Dancing With The Moonlit Knight (8:01)
2. I Know What I Like (In Your Wardrobe) (4:06)
3. Firth Of Fifth (9:34)
4. More Fool Me (3:09)
5. The Battle Of Epping Forest(11:43)
6. After The Ordeal (4:12)
7. The Cinema Show (11:06)
8. Aisle Of Plenty (1:31)
Album length: 53:22