Not Your Kind of People

0 10

Author: Peter Podbrežnik

Artist: Garbage
Label: Stun Volume Records
Release: 2012
Length: 42:50
Rating: 4/5

International alternative rock band Garbage, who have sold more than 17 million albums worldwide over their career, are best known for their charismatic Scottish singer Shirley Manson, though the rest of the crew, guitarist Steve Marker, bassist/guitarist/keyboardist Duke Erikson and drummer Butch Vig, are also respected as established producers and sound engineers. They broke through commercially in the nineties, starting with hit singles like »Stupid Girl« and »Only Happy When It Rains«, followed by the studio debut »Garbage« (1995), and crowned it all with its successor »Version 2.0« (1998), which earned them two Grammy nominations, for Album of the Year and Best Rock Album.

The winning streak of the fiery-haired Scot and her three American bandmates came to a halt with »Beautiful Garbage« (2001), a commercial flop on every front that eventually led to their (temporary) breakup in 2003. Fans of those digitally compressed vocals and dynamic electronic beats didn’t have to wait long for a comeback, though. Just two years later they rose ‘from the dead’ with their fourth album, »Bleed Like Me«, which did pretty well for them. During the hiatus between 2006 and 2009, Manson focused on her solo career (we’re still waiting for her debut) and, among other things, tried her hand at acting in the popular TV series Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles, where she played a sexy liquid-metal terminator.

After a six-year break, Garbage have finally returned with new material, »Not Your Kind of People«, their fifth studio album. It’s fair to say they’ve fully lived up to the high expectations of their longtime fans. One of the main reasons, if not the main one, why Garbage have always stood out from the crowd of similar alternative rock bands with an electronic rhythmic pedigree is that the charismatic Manson boasts a truly distinctive voice. It’s melodic and rasping enough to be charming, which makes their music commercially appealing to radio stations worldwide, yet there’s not a shred of annoyance or whiny ‘moaning’ in it, the kind we all too often have to put up with from her peers. Manson has also been an experienced keyboardist since the mid-eighties, when she played in the alt-rock bands Goodbye Mr. MacKenzie  and Angelfish, so she effectively helps Erikson keep the layered electronic rhythms going.

As expected, on their latest outing Garbage stay true to their alt-rock legacy, with a heavy emphasis on plenty of digital effects and electronically tinged rhythms that at times recall the golden age of new wave synth music. Maybe the girl and the guys (in truth, they’ve all been well into their years for a while now) overdo the vocoder here and there, but that’s an integral part of their tradition. »Not Your Kind of People« also boasts excellent production, which is no surprise, since all four musicians have been authorities in that field for ages.

The album has a dark, melodramatic edge, as the opener »Automatic Systematic Habit« proves right away. It’s made to the taste of all the longtime Garbage fans: a melody built on an expressive vocal drenched in digital effects, greased with wide layers of electronic rhythms. »Big Bright World«, with its noticeable new wave stamp, is another triumph of electronic oscillation over fast-paced beats. »Blood For Poppies«, which was available as a digital download on the band’s website even before the album came out, was released as a single, which was a good call, since amid dirty guitar distortion and electronic samples it delivers a quickly infectious, melodic and uplifting chorus, the kind you can’t do without if you want to grab radio stations’ attention. Artistically even more polished and complex, »Control« delivers a neat fusion of innovative electronic samples, lively rhythms and a mighty, atmospherically rich chorus. The title track has a psychedelic, dreamy vibe, the result of a mix of a gentle acoustic guitar melody, multi-part vocal lines, mischievous digital patterns and slow beats. The end result is the most atmospherically deep and interesting piece on the entire album. »Felt« has an almost danceable, electronically seasoned rhythm, and »I Hate Love« is a pure triumph of electronic rhythmic synth where you can feel the atmospheric chill of the ‘robot age’, in which all emotion is suppressed in favor of cold reason, while Shirley’s singing, compressed through a vocal effect, effectively brings in some contrasting warmth.

»Sugar« is another atmospheric contrast, with Manson suddenly sounding almost shamelessly seductive while synth curtains in the background create a hypnotic mood. The considerably more aggressive »Battle In Me« was released as the album’s first single and is aimed primarily at the European market, which has always handled guitar distortion better than the softened-up Americans. Manson again backs up her aggressive singing approach with heavy use of the vocoder in the chorus, while dynamic rhythmic shifts keep her company and cement the single’s overall commercial potential. »Man On a Wire« also belongs to the handful of atmospherically more agitated tracks, with Vig’s vehement torture of the drum kit, while the passionate redhead once again impresses with her vocal chameleonism. The closer »Beloved Freak« is a successful fusion of a gentle piano melody, electronic rhythmic seasoning, rich synth curtains and Shirley’s velvety-rasping voice. The end result is a solemn and optimistic mood that stands in sharp contrast to the generally rather gloomy nature of this record.

»Not Your Kind of People« is an album with a generous dose of seductive artistry, made to the taste of most longtime Garbage fans, and so it marks a successful comeback for this cult band on the music scene. Manson and her three American buddies prove that even on an alt-rock scene that’s often creatively exhausted and abused by the mass media, they’re still capable of a few pleasant surprises, which, as in their case, are most often the fruit of long experience and artistic seasoning.

Lineup

Shirley Manson – vocals, keyboards
Steve Marker – guitar
Duke Erikson – bass, guitar, keyboards
Butch Vig – drums, percussion

 

Production

Garbage

Tracklist

1. Automatic Systematic Habit
2. Big Bright World
3. Blood for Poppies
4. Control
5. Not Your Kind of People
6. Felt
7. I Hate Love
8. Sugar
9. Battle in Me
10. Man on a Wire
11. Beloved Freak

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.

This website uses cookies to provide online services, advertising systems and functionality that we would not be able to offer without cookies. By visiting and using the website, you consent to the use of cookies. Accept Read more

Privacy & cookies