Emerson, Lake & Palmer: In the Hot Seat

0 448

Release date: 09/27/1994
Label: Victory
Production: Keith Olsen
Length: 46:05
Genre: symphonic progressive rock
Rating: 3/10

The studio career of prog rock legends Emerson, Lake & Palmer ended on a pretty sad note with the below-average “In the Hot Seat”, an album that was anything but worthy of their famous and hugely influential legacy. Heated debates still rage among their fans over which is the worst studio album in ELP history: “In the Hot Seat” or “Love Beach” (1978). While it was being made, “In the Hot Seat” — the only album by the celebrated trio that never got any real commercial response — seemed like it would be a continuation of the comeback story. After the unexciting but decent ‘return’ album “Black Moon” (1992), ELP looked to be riding a successful return to an increasingly lively prog rock scene, but in reality the relationships inside the star-studded trio, especially between Keith Emerson and Greg Lake, both sadly no longer with us, were already badly frayed.

Emerson was dealing with health problems at the time, since inflamed nerves in his right hand made it hard for him to play keyboards properly, and he also had quite different songwriting ideas from Lake, whose compositional outlook by then didn’t stretch much beyond love ballads. Greg was also unhappy that Emerson wouldn’t let him take on the traditional producer role, as on all previous ELP albums except “Black Moon”, and instead hired Keith Olsen for “In the Hot Seat”. Olsen had spent most of his career as a producer specializing in AOR bands, and in ELP’s case he wasn’t exactly the happiest choice. Carl Palmer, the youngest and apparently the wisest of the legendary trio, probably already sensed in 1994 that ELP were in the studio together for the last time in their story.

You can hear how songwriting-wise completely drained and sick of each other ELP were on “In the Hot Seat” right from the opener “Hand of Truth”. Stylistically it picks up where “Black Moon” left off, but it lacks the ambient magic, the rhythmic variety and that real elan that was once so typical of the cult trio; Lake’s already noticeably diminished vocals sound emotionally hollow, while Emerson’s keyboard arrangements are more like a generic symphonic backdrop for film music than anything resembling the old eclectic masterpieces. “Daddy” is Lake’s AOR-leaning power ballad, dedicated to the memory of the missing girl Sara Anne Wood, with lyrics that draw attention to the problem of missing children. Sadly, it turned out pretty uninspired.

Most of the material, like the below-average “One by One”, is a rather tasteless mix of unimaginative symphonic prog with painfully generic symphonic arrangements and second-rate AOR, next to which even the worst effort by Asia sounds brilliant. Maybe Emerson can be partly forgiven for his much reduced activity given his health problems at the time, which is why his keyboard wizardry is sorely missed throughout “In the Hot Seat”, but his songwriting ideas were also below the expected standard, so the album as a whole is a really painful listening experience.

Palmer didn’t have much to do on drums either, and only rarely in his long and colorful career has he sounded as lifeless as on “In the Hot Seat”. Lake’s vocals, as already mentioned, were nowhere near their former level, while his acoustic-leaning love ballads like “Heart of Ice” had by this point become thoroughly generic and uninspired. One of the crowning proofs of that is the almost humiliating cover of Dylan’s classic “Man in the Long Black Coat”, where you can barely tell it’s the band that once created masterpieces like “Tarkus” (1971), “Trilogy” (1972) and “Brain Salad Surgery” (1973). The bonus tracks on the reissue of “In the Hot Seat” don’t impress either, especially the newly played studio version of “Pictures of an Exhibition”, which is merely a pale shadow of the magnificent live version released on the album of the same name in 1971.

With the crushingly dull “In the Hot Seat”, their last and probably worst studio effort, ELP hit their creative rock bottom, and even though they kept going as a live outfit for another four years, it was clear that this was now really the end of the road. It’s kind of sad that a supergroup like this made all its best work in the first half of the seventies, and after getting back together in the early nineties, they no longer had the real desire, energy or motivation to try to get anywhere near their old lofty artistic standards, even though “Black Moon” was far from a bad record. If nothing else, ELP at least bowed out in a dignified way with an unforgettable final performance at the High Voltage festival in 2010. Emerson’s life ended tragically in 2016 with suicide, and Lake passed away the same year too. That leaves Palmer as the only surviving and active member of what was once an enormously successful musical story, still playing the music of the legendary trio as a solo performer.

author: Peter Podbrežnik

track list:
1. Hand of Truth
2. Daddy
3. One by One
4. Heart on Ice
5. Thin Line
6. Man in the Long Black Coat
7. Change
8. Give Me a Reason to Stay
9. Gone Too Soon
10. Street War
CD bonus track:
11. Pictures at an Exhibition
a. Promenade
b. The Gnome
c. Promenade
d. The Sage
e. The Hut of Baba Yaga
f. The Great Gates of Kiev

Emerson, Lake & Palmer:
Keith Emerson – keyboards
Greg Lake – vocals, guitar, bass guitar
Carl Palmer – drums

guest musicians:
Bill Wray – backing vocals
Paula Mattioli – backing vocals
Kristen Olsen – additional vocals on “Daddy”
Fred White – choir vocals on “Pictures at an Exhibition”
Ricky Nelson – choir vocals on “Pictures at an Exhibition”
Lynn B. Davis – choir vocals on “Pictures at an Exhibition”
Linda McCrary – choir vocals on “Pictures at an Exhibition”

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.

This website uses cookies to provide online services, advertising systems and functionality that we would not be able to offer without cookies. By visiting and using the website, you consent to the use of cookies. Accept Read more

Privacy & cookies