Spirit of Eden
Author: Peter Podbrežnik
Artist: Talk Talk
Label: Parlophone Records
Release: 1988
Duration: 41:30
Rating: 5/5
»Spirit of Eden« was one of the best albums of the 1980s, and it unwittingly laid the foundations for a new musical movement, so-called post-rock, even though it took many more years before most music critics recognized its true artistic value. This album by the English experimentalists Talk Talk was completely different from anything they had made up to that point, and it wasn’t related in genre to anything that was getting played on the music scene at the time either. »Spirit of Eden« was such an innovative, revolutionary achievement for its time that it thoroughly baffled and divided the critics, while earning the band even greater respect from music connoisseurs and cementing their cult status as one of the few groups of the eighties more interested in finding the limits of their sonic evolution than in cranking out big hits. True to its fascinating, utterly unique sound, »Spirit of Eden« was strikingly non-commercial and didn’t have a single hit on it, which was a huge break from Talk Talk’s past.
Talk Talk were led by the charismatic and unpredictable singer and guitarist Mark Hollis, who after 1986 decided that his musical collective would work only as a studio band and recorded his compositions in the dark, by candlelight, to achieve an even better ambient effect, and they were visionaries without parallel. On various occasions Hollis said that his musical roots lay in 20th-century classical music and jazz, and that he wanted to take Talk Talk there sonically too, but the synthesizer technology of the day had, ‘out of necessity,’ shackled them to new wave until they finally blossomed into great sonic and ambient experimentalists on the album »The Colour of Spring« (1986).
Even the excellent »The Colour of Spring«, which was really a transitional album between the early, new wave Talk Talk and the later jazzy-ambient (these days you could also say post-rock) Talk Talk, proved with its many loose, jazz-spiced forms and rolling ambient layers where the band would be dragged sonically on »Spirit of Eden«. During the recording of the »Spirit of Eden« material, there were numerous disputes between Talk Talk and their label EMI, which demanded nothing but new hits and didn’t understand Hollis’s sonic vision. Most of the EMI higher-ups had no clue what was going on in Hollis’s head, and as they listened to the new compositions they scratched their heads in bewilderment and resigned themselves to the fact that this time they could no longer count on any commercial success. Given all that, it’s really no wonder that right after the release of »Spirit of Eden«, which came out on EMI’s subsidiary Parlophone Records, Talk Talk signed a new contract with the label Polydor.
Sound engineer Phill Brown and Hollis’s ‘outside’ musical sidekick and producer Tim-Friese Greene, who delivered the divine production that let »Spirit of Eden« pass the test of time in a phenomenally good way, as if it had been recorded yesterday, must have experienced the recording process as an extremely intense and unpredictable ordeal. Candlelight was reportedly the only source of illumination in the total gloom that reigned in the studio, so the band could achieve maximum ambient effect, which still thrills today with its incredible expressive depth. Some other musicians learned plenty from a similar example too, for instance Marillion singer Steve Hogarth.
Minimalist keyboard curtains, or so-called soundscapes (mostly on piano, organ and with the help of various guitar effects), directed by Hollis and his ‘outside’ sidekick Tim-Friese Greene, together with delicate guitar improvisations, played the lion’s share in creating an incredibly rich sound, blending elements of free jazz and classical music, while Talk Talk also made heavy use of the technique of sonic ‘overdubbing.’ The number of guest musicians was fascinating, led by an impressive orchestral section where everyone left their own sonic stamp on individual compositions, while the arrangement and ambient core rested on the Talk Talk trio, made up of Hollis plus bassist Paul Webb and drummer Lee Harris.
The central role in creating the melodramatic moods, just like on the previous three Talk Talk albums, fell to Hollis’s utterly unique vocals, which floor you at every turn with their exceptional emotional weight. Hollis’s lyrics were a chapter of their own too, as they were quite spiritual, even though he was never a member of any organized religion, which means that despite their apparent minimalism, they offer plenty of food for the brain and above all for the heart. Personally, Mr. Hollis reportedly prefers to describe them as humanist rather than spiritual.
This is an album you simply must not listen to with rational perception, but with the heart, and only then does all its depth and true artistic value reveal itself. Every listen uncovers something new. »The Rainbow« opens with a jazzy-ambient arrangement where a trumpet pushes through the minimalist keyboard curtains. In time Hollis’s guitar variation drops in, undisturbed by the playful sounds of the harmonica. His distinctive voice, alongside subtle piano embellishments, deepens the mysterious, ethereal and melancholic atmosphere even further, which is especially fitting for listening on rainy days. »Eden« is also a track laced with the free jazz forms that always fascinated Hollis so much. Once again it’s his emotionally rich and unpredictable voice that drives this fascinating composition to an ambient climax, while minimalist percussion and ‘floating’ piano arrangements make sure the sound is really filled out to the max.
»Desire« enchants in its opening part with its exceptional ambient beauty, achieved through an interweaving of harmonious classical-jazz variations, followed by an unexpected turn into a fiery section with Hollis’s chameleon-moody vocals, ruffled guitar passages and a lively performance from the Harris-Webb rhythm section, which is also one of the few more ‘conventional’ rock moments on »Spirit of Eden«. The combination of extremely fragile piano arrangements and a melancholic trumpet makes for a string of deeply intimate moments. A heated improvisational section, where Harris unleashes a crazy drum solo, offers fine proof that »Spirit of Eden« isn’t dominated solely by ethereal ‘daydreaming,’ and that Hollis’s crew was positively bursting with energy.
The deeply melancholic »Inheritance« is also a highly interesting piece, where Hollis’s singing, amid piano and percussion minimalism, is full of pain, while mighty orchestral arrangements flow in the background. »I Believe in You«, with its socially conscious lyrics, warns about the consequences of heroin addiction, though it’s worth noting that this wasn’t Hollis’s own experience or confession. With his singing and interesting guitar improvisations, Hollis shapes a melancholic motif that then starts repeating over the rolling arrangements, while the members of Talk Talk and the other musical collaborators keep adding new sonic embellishments. For a moment they almost ‘renounce’ the aforementioned motif and slip into free jazz forms, but then they return to it and wrap everything up in a melodic, ambiently very pleasant way.
»Wealth« is the closing track, where Hollis once again enchants with his emotional vocal range, in perfect harmony with the symphonic, piano-and-organ undulation. The mighty sound of a harmonium is also clearly audible here, which only heightens the sacral, spiritual mood that, with its expressive depth, completely captures heart and soul. The lyrics contain a more than obvious, slightly mocking allusion to how Hollis couldn’t have cared less about any commercial success and would rather lead his band into obscurity than keep filling concert halls like there was no tomorrow.
The masterpiece »Spirit of Eden« was a revolutionary album, one that a whole legion of post-rock bands and alternative acts would later adopt as ‘their own.’ With its otherness and experimentalism, which in ethos recalled the golden age of progressive rock, it completely split the fans and critics of the time on release, yet some listeners realized even then that Talk Talk had made their magnum opus. At the same time it was a unique manifesto of artistic originality and boldness, with a complete disregard for the trends and demands of the music industry of the day. It’s truly incredible how far ahead of their time Hollis’s musical visions were, which he went on to develop further on the next stylistically related Talk Talk album, »Laughing Stock« (1991), which then turned out to be their final achievement.
Lineup
Mark Hollis – vocals, piano, organ, guitar
Lee Harris – drums
Paul Webb – electric bass guitar
GUEST MUSICIANS
Tim Friese-Greene – harmonium, piano, organ, guitar
Martin Ditcham – percussion
Robbie McIntosh – dobro, 12-string guitar
Mark Feltham – harmonica
Simon Edwards – mehiški bas
Danny Thompson – double bass
Henry Lowther – trumpet
Nigel Kennedy – violin
Hugh Davies – shozygs
Andrew Stowell – bassoon
Michael Jeans – oboe
Andrew Marriner – clarinet
Christopher Hooker – English horn
Choir of Chelmsford Cathedral
Production
Tim Friese-Greene
Track list
1. The Rainbow (9:05)
2. Eden (6:37)
3. Desire (7:08)
4. Inheritance (5:16)
5. I Believe in You (6:24)
6. Wealth (6:35)