TGBE!

0 7

Artist: Guilty Brothers Experiment, The
Label: Still
Released: 2010
Runtime: 57.00
Rating: 3.5/5

If you want to end up in the madhouse, or you’re desperately itching to be declared monumentally nuts, go ahead and spin this album right now. I can’t remember the last time I heard this much musical chaos piled up in one place! Retro, trendy and avant-garde all at once? A mess and a half. And yet it’s not without substance.

You could call it an experimental indie rock debut, in a way. One with a strong streak of wanting to express its own artistry, its own take on musical information. The guys clearly wanted to make a different kind of album. One that puts them on the musical map as special and recognizable. To a certain extent, they actually pull it off. But at what price?

This album is an extremely heavy slab of cake. Some of the “cracklings” can sit in your digestive tract a lot longer than you’d planned. So it smells like an experiment that will only appeal to the most demanding listeners. The ones looking for something special, different, standing out. Fresh, definitely. And, of course, a bit bonkers at the same time.

Picture Robert Smith (The Cure) wandering into independent, avant-garde-minded musical messaging. A shrieking, frenzied, wheezy high vocal is therefore guaranteed. It’s close to Robert Smith’s tone, which means it embodies certain quirks that also act as the first sieve through which potential listeners get strained, splitting them into fans and those who steer clear of the band in a wide arc. The vocal approach also comes with the connotation of an alternative rock frontman. The vocal often resorts to deliberate dissonance, which cements the alternative stamp on The Guilty Brothers Experiment. Through its deviant howling, the voice is often used as an extra instrument. Its shrieking lines can also fill out the background of the soundscape.

The instrumentalists drag out impulses from musical deeds of the past, especially from bands that were putting out albums in the seventies. A time when nearly every album uncovered a new musical dimension. So we get a neat combination of half-step-detuned Sabbath-style riffs and, to some extent, escalations of Floydian psychedelia (the track Musical Chairs II), which in terms of modern production evokes the musical state of bands from Oceansize to The Mars Volta (especially some of the solutions in the lines the singer falls back on). There’s actually no similarity in motifs with the latter band, though. And the opening Overture? You could easily mistake it for the recent history of musical “pranks” by the experimental pioneers of their era, from Gong to Hawkwind. Off the wall from the very first second. By now you’ve probably gotten thoroughly confused, and just so you stay confused, let me throw in that some passages are underpinned by totally simple rhythmic solutions. Laid over that lazy drumming is a swaying on just one or two notes coaxed out of the guitar. When the vocal screaming joins that combination, the guys brush up against something that appeared on the planet in the second half of the eighties and was called post punk rock. And in the new era, borrowing from post punk means only this. Stuff like A Song Of Hate And Hope, Entracte and As Guilty As Possible gets close to the sonic territory of indie rockers like The Dandy Warhols, Interpol, Editors, Killers.

The shifts from one musical sphere to another are unexpected, things unfold spontaneously and the mood swings are completely unpredictable. The plus here is that this hopping between (almost) musical genres isn’t “chopped off” and devoid of any sense in the songwriting. So the whole thing stays compact, and there’s no danger of reckless moves from incompatible composing that would lead to a final state of unlistenable musical fragmentation. Everything fits together. At the same time, it shamelessly hints that the content on the disc in front of us is demanding. The rhythm often breaks in the songs, and tracks can turn into an eruptive closing “crescendo” that drives the listener to the limit of the acceptable, as we get in the track Overskies Telegram. That’s by far the most experimental moment of the album. If you make it through that “normally” (read: without brain damage), you’ll have passed the endurance test with flying colors!

So the album is multilayered. A bunch of guest musicians help with that, and they obviously got more than just permission to take absolute creative freedom, further enriching and expanding the album’s message that way. Honestly, the only less interesting move on the album is its ending. After the drawn-out progressive experiment in Musical Chairs II, two shorter tracks follow. The first is the instrumental Ôde à Lou, the second Fermeture. They don’t depart from the stretched-out Musical Chairs II in any way, so they could easily have stayed folded into that 10-plus-minute musical spaghetti.

The album “TGBE!” is an experimental beast. You can file it under progressive rock. But it also includes an element of alternative rock. So it’s about combining elements of the legacy of old bands with the reach of modern rock, especially when it comes to production, of course. The strength of this album is that it managed to present something different, fresh and therefore interesting. But to do that, the guys had to reach back and take cues from the past. It doesn’t bring a musical revolution, and it doesn’t quite earn the “avant-garde” label, even though it’s trying hard to smell like it. So “TGBE!” is an album for those with the thickest skin. For anyone whose skin could survive even an atomic war! The multilayered approach gives the band plenty of cues for its musical direction and expressive profile going forward. And that’s certainly one of its strengths, especially when you need to adapt fast and change the color of your coat. So it’ll be interesting to see what happens with The Guilty Brothers Experience next! The musicians in this band are really high quality and highly receptive to a new challenge!

Lineup

Joly – drums
Bob Litter – bass guitar
Anton Chagrin – guitar, backing vocals
Sal Jean Satin – guitar
Jason Gé – vocals, percussion

GUEST MUSICIANS:
Toma Venegoni – organ, keyboards, piano (tracks 1, 4 & 9)
Manu Hermia – saxophone, bansuri (tracks 7 & 8)
Jeuc Dietrich – Hurdy Gurdy, viola (tracks 1 & 10)
Jennifer El Gammal – trombone (tracks 6 & 8)
Julien Vanderstichelen Rogier – vocals (tracks 2, 3 & 6)
Jimmy Pierrot & Justin Wansart (Voltvoice) – guitars (track 9)
François Vincent – keyboards (tracks 2 & 5)
Valentine & Charlotte – vocals (track 9)
Lou – narration (track 11)

Production

The Guilty Brothers Experiment & Rudy Coclet

Track list

1. Ouverture
2. A Strange Valley of Exile
3. Hesitation of Icarus
4. Roses & Rue (Part. I)
5. Roses & Rue (Part. II)
6. A Song of Hate & Hope
7. Entracte
8. Overskies Telegram (Including the March of Death)
9. As Guilty As Possible
10. Musical Chairs II (After the Rain)
11. Ôde à Lou
12. Fermeture

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.

This website uses cookies to provide online services, advertising systems and functionality that we would not be able to offer without cookies. By visiting and using the website, you consent to the use of cookies. Accept Read more

Privacy & cookies