The Anatomy of Melancholy
Author: Rok Klemše
Artist: Paradise Lost
Label: Century Media
Release: 2008
British band Paradise Lost have a hugely colorful twenty-year career behind them, one with plenty of ups and downs. Already with their debut album Lost Paradise (1990), alongside fellow Brits Anathema and My Dying Bride, they were seen as the founders of the death/doom metal genre. Paradise Lost quickly brought melody, clean vocals (female ones too) and symphonic touches into their music, and to this day they’re considered true pioneers and innovators of gothic metal. Their second album Gothic (1991) is still regarded as one of the most influential in the genre, and critics and fans alike unanimously declared it an eternal classic. Over the next few albums Paradise Lost built a name as one of the biggest death/doom and gothic metal bands, and in 1997 they released One Second, on which they flirted with Depeche Mode-style synth-pop and electronics. On the next album, the controversial Host (1999), they forgot their metal roots completely, and plenty of old fans turned their backs on them. It was only with the 2005 album Paradise Lost that the band returned to its metal sound and announced a long-awaited return to form. Last year’s In Requiem only confirmed it: Paradise Lost are back!
Riding the wave of that success (In Requiem was welcomed with open arms by fans and critics alike), Paradise Lost also recorded a fresh live CD/DVD release last year. The Anatomy of Melancholy is the release in front of us, recorded at Koko in London on April 12, 2007. After the fiasco of the Evolve DVD with the Live at Sheppard’s Bush recording, which was sunk mainly by Nick Holmes’s dreadful vocal performance, it was high time for Paradise Lost to make amends. And with this release they pull it off completely. The production of the recording is downright fantastic: the sound is sharp, mighty, clear and clean, and the band is at the peak of its powers. The guitars are loud and bombastic, nicely complementing the excellent drumming of Jeff Singer, probably the best drummer Paradise Lost have ever had (a shame he left the band after the last album, but the band’s used to it, since throughout their entire history only the drummers have ever changed in Paradise Lost). He also does a lot to make the band sound even tighter, more complete and more unified. The bass is pushed a bit further back in the mix, but it fills out the sonic picture nicely. The most impressive part of the recording, though, is definitely vocalist Nick Holmes, whose contribution to the whole thing was always in question. On the Evolve DVD he butchers at least three quarters of the footage, but luckily on this DVD he hits his vocal peak and shines like never before. Emotional and heartfelt, and on the tracks Eternal and Gothic he even sings with a somewhat weak, rough part that recalls his early growling. The crowd is into it, Nick manages to fire them up nicely, and it’s easy to imagine yourself standing in the middle of Koko at the gig. The band kicks off with the excellent opener of the In Requiem record, The Enemy, which comes across as crushing and bombastic live, proof that Paradise Lost’s latest record takes them back to their glory days of years ago. Especially when the band follows it with Praise Lamented Shade in epic proportions. The setlist is nicely rounded out by the rarely played Sweetness from the Seals the Sense single and Forever Failure, introduced by a sample of Charles Manson’s last video interview: “I don’t know what sorry means”. The setlist is effectively mixed with songs from all the albums, though the album Gothic would surely deserve a spot or two more, and above all there’s a lack of tracks from Icon and Shades of God. From the controversial Host, which even Holmes himself labels that way, they could have picked a better song than So Much Is Lost, while the real treats of the album hide in the half-speed Embers Fire, Pity the Sadness, the interestingly played Mouth, in which guitars replace all the electronic and keyboard parts, and the anthemic As I Die. Paradise Lost standardly close the show with their best-known song, the club hit Say Just Words from the album One Second. A gig this good would definitely deserve a slightly better ending. A nice extra in the booklet are the “liner notes” in which Nick and guitarist Greg Mackintosh present each individual track in a humorous and entertaining way.
The Anatomy of Melancholy is without a doubt a must-buy for every Paradise Lost fan, and it’s great to hear that a band that spent several years drifting in mediocrity is returning to its old glory. It’s even better to hear that the band sounds just as good live as it does on this recording.
Line-up
Nick Holmes – vocals
Gregor Mackintosh – guitar
Aaron Aedy – guitar
Stephen Edmondson – bass
Jeff Singer – drums
Production
Jens Bogren
Track list
CD 1
1.Intro
2.The Enemy
3.Grey
4.Erased
5.Red Shift
6.So Much Is Lost
7.Sweetness
8.Praise Lamented Shade
9.Pity the Sadness
10.Forever Failure
11.Once Solemn
12.As I Die
CD 2
1.Embers Fire
2.Mouth
3.No Celebration
4.Eternal
5.True Belief
6.One Second
7.The Last Time
8.Gothic
9.Say Just Words