The Battle of Hastings
Author: Peter Podbrežnik
Artist: Caravan
Label: Transatlantic Records
Released: 1995
Length: 52:21
Rating: 3.5/5
The Battle of Hastings was a turning point in English history, bringing William the Conqueror to the throne and ushering in the long reign of the warlike Normans over England. But »The Battle of Hastings« is also the title of the twelfth studio album by Caravan, legends of the Canterbury progressive rock scene. It came out in the fall of 1995, thirteen years after their last ‘regular’ album, »Back to Front« (1992), and a year after »Cool Water« (1994), a collection of material from 1977 that had been ‘patched together’.
The album title is basically a nod to the surname of Caravan’s longtime chieftain, guitarist and singer Pye Hastings, but it also fits right in with the Old English aura that has trailed this legendary band practically since day one. In the first half of the nineties, Hastings played live alongside keyboardist David Sinclair as a member of the progressive rock (super)group Mirage, made up of former members of Camel and Caravan. With backing and encouragement from the HTD label, Hastings and Sinclair decided to record a completely new Caravan album, which came as a big, pleasant surprise even to the most devoted longtime fans.
They were joined in the studio by original drummer Richard Coughlan, sadly no longer with us, returning violist and second guitarist Geoffrey Richardson, and new bassist Jim Leverton (ex-Blodwyn Pig, Steve Marriott). After original member Richard Sinclair ‘flaked’ once again, it was Richardson, an old buddy of Leverton’s, who suggested him to Pye as Caravan’s new bass player. Pye’s brother and longtime ‘outside’ collaborator Jimmy Hastings was back as guest woodwind player and in great spirits while the individual tracks were being recorded. The most pleasant, modern novelty in the Caravan sound, though, was the addition of mandolins.
»The Battle of Hastings« is marked by a sonic revitalization and is at least a partly successful return by Caravan to their old, recognizable arrangement standards, since most of the compositions written by Pye Hastings are once again at a high level. Sinclair’s songwriting and keyboard contribution found particular success on the commercially minded »Travelling Ways«, with Leverton on lead vocals. It instantly got airplay on radio stations all over Great Britain, which for a (pioneering) progressive rock band in the mid-nineties was a success bordering on science fiction. In Ireland, »Travelling Ways« even climbed close to the top of the student music chart, helped along no doubt by its boozy, un-Caravan-like pub atmosphere and a song structure that’s somewhat reminiscent of so-called pub rock and folk rock.
Richardson’s return meant more of the sparkling string arrangements that thrilled listeners in the past, even though some songs on »The Battle of Hastings« still had more in common with pop rock, or at most art rock, than with progressive rock. A case in point is »Liar«, which, mostly thanks to the chorus and the synth textures, has almost more in common with melodic rock/AOR than with prog, even if individual arrangements are still tied to the sonic legacy of this legendary group.
The opener, an acoustic-guitar-tinged number called »It’s a Sad, Sad Affair«, instantly recalls some Caravan standards from the distant past, with the important difference that everything here is subordinated to melody and there’s no trace of any complex improvisations. The ballads »Somewhere In Your Heart« and »Cold As Ice«, adorned with stately orchestral arrangements (the gorgeous strings on the latter are especially impressive), also stir up nostalgia for past classics, though they’re ‘light-years’ away from what Caravan were capable of at their best. The burlesque »Wendy Wants Another 6” Mole”«, which pokes fun at the vain floozy Wendy, is a mischievous and endearing proof that over the years the members of Caravan haven’t lost the sparkling, cheeky humor that marked the lyrics of some of their most beloved past efforts. Optimists and jokers alike will find the album closing with »I Know Why You’re Laughing«, where their refined feel for laying down melodic rhythmic structures and shaping lovely vocal harmonies once again shines under Pye’s eager vocal command.
»The Battle of Hastings« was an unexciting but still solid comeback for the Canterbury champions everyone had all but written off. Practically nobody outside the band’s inner circle was expecting a new studio album back then, and the fact that it was their most interesting effort since »Blind Dog At St. Dunstans’« in 1976 undoubtedly helped Caravan hold their ground on the prog rock scene after 1995, a scene that was going through huge changes at the time as interest in the pioneers of the genre woke up again.
Lineup
Pye Hastings – vocals, electric guitar
Dave Sinclair – keyboards, backing vocals
Richard Coughlan – drums
Jim Leverton – bass guitar, backing vocals
Geoff Richardson – acoustic guitar, clarinet, mandolin, violin, electric guitar, backing vocals
GUEST MUSICIAN:
Jimmy Hastings – woodwinds
Production
Caravan
Tracklist
1. It’s a Sad, Sad Affair
2. Somewhere in Your Heart
3. Cold as Ice
4. Liar
5- Don’t Want Love
6. Travelling Ways
7. This Time
8. If It Wasn’t for Your Ego
9. It’s Not Real
10. Wendy Wants Another 6″ Mole”
11. I Know Why You’re Laughing