The Great Prophecy of a Small Man
Artist: Modest Midget
Label: Self-released
Released: 2010
Runtime: 46:49
Rating: 5/5
If you’re looking for something different in pop/rock, something new and above all good, if you’re sick of the mediocrity of sugary melodies and clichéd lyrics with zero creativity, then Modest Midget are the band for you. The Dutchmen don’t hide the fact that a big chunk of their music is straight-up pop, but they don’t even try to stay inside the genre’s lines, because there’s a ton of jazz, rock, blues and ethno (mainly klezmer and Eastern European melos) in there. The song structures themselves are insanely complex, so I can easily say the band plays progressive pop/rock. Inside their pop “frame,” though, the musicians mostly goof around and clown about, and you can hear a big influence from the British Canterbury scene, yet Modest Midget stay their own beast in all their silliness. That’s exactly why they get lumped in with their countrymen Supersister, a legendary prog band that never waded into symphonic prog rock or progressive metal like most of the big Dutch bands of that scene (Focus, Kayak, Ayreon), but found their role model mainly in the British Canterbury scene. But Modest Midget’s music is a lot more than that. The way they play with melodies often recalls another legendary group, The Beatles, while the occasional falsetto singing, mostly from Lionel “Lonny” Ziblat, sounds like Gentle Giant frontman Derek Shulman; the playful vocal fooling around also brings to mind Rikard Sjöblom, singer of Sweden’s Beardfish. The falsetto is more prominent on the four tracks from Modest Midget’s EP “Partial Exposure” (PE for short, which is EP spelled backwards), which also show up on “The Great Prophecy of a Small Man”; still, the vocals never reach the huge, rough range Shulman had in Gentle Giant. Well, the band name Modest Midget probably came about because of Gentle Giant’s influence on the musicians in the first place.
On “The Great Prophecy of a Small Man” the song lengths are definitely not prog rock style, mostly sitting between three and five minutes, as befits a pop-standard tune. You can actually dance to these songs, even though the notice on Modest Midget’s website is practically glowing at us, telling us not to expect music we’ll start swaying to. Taking that on board, the album could even be labeled “anti-prog,” even though the construction of the tracks is almost genius. After the short intro “Follow the Noise,” a heap of escalating menacing sounds that ends in nothing more than today’s radio static, the album serves up Modest Midget’s best song, “Contemporary Ache.” A mix of “Crimson-esque” experimental sound and “Gentle Giant-ish” eccentric melodies is excellently backed by a one-of-a-kind lyric. So many clever implications woven so originally into just a few rhymes are hard to come by these days, especially since the lyric’s topic is music and its history. And as much as the song gives lyrically, it gives just as much instrumentally. In the solo sections it’s downright incredible to listen to such an interweaving of fun major-key melodies, backed by Eastern melos and proper “Zappa-esque” transitions.
If “Contemporary Ache” was still more or less a rock song, “Trouble in Heaven” is pure pop-tune material. A melodramatic concept with vocal tug-of-wars between three different voices paints us a vivid musical. With its rock’n’roll and blues sections, witty clapping between riffs of distorted guitar and almost clownish woodwind and keyboard sounds, there’s no way you can take Modest Midget seriously. The compositional fusion of all these elements into a working whole is truly breathtaking. “Troubles in Heaven” is thus another high-flying piece that can almost stand shoulder to shoulder with “Contermporary Ache.”
The first flaw only shows up on the third track, “Coffee From Yesterday.” The fully instrumental piece is nicely set up, at least as far as the melodic components go, but the rhythm section is almost annoying. The overly monotonous and, above all, unsuitable drumming fights with the strong guitar lines and keyboard arrangements. Still, it works very well as an overture to its successor “Back From My Trip.” Here Ziblat shows off all his guitar vehemence through a funny lyric about a trip around the world that the lyrical subject isn’t ready for. With no deeper meaning, the song is lyrically mostly Modest Midget messing around, this time through words rather than instruments. A much more clichéd lyrical approach can be heard on “Home Seek,” where the theme is unrequited love. Still, that cliché comes wrapped in far more thoughtful lyrics, incredible vocal harmony and perfect instrumental support, with phenomenal guitar and keyboard bits in the pauses between the pompous vocal games that are the heart of this ballad.
“Here I Go” is another pop-tune feat for Ziblat vocally, with a lyric pulling a similar move: the lyrical subject wants a woman and is convinced he can’t fail. Instrumentally the track grows into a progressive rock symphony, where Ziblat shines again in the solos with his guitar chops. With all this, “Here I Go” is and isn’t aimed at a radio audience, since it has so much more, too much, for an average pop song. On the next ballad, “Baby,” Modest Midget once again glance toward the witty eccentricity of Gentle Giant and the rest of the Canterbury scene. A pleasantly funny lyric makes “Baby” yet another piece in the style so far, fresh and somehow innovative, yet still very “familiar.” The depth of the lyric is easy to spot, and instrumentally the interweaving of the melody with violin is welcome, undermining your first impressions of expected clichés.
After “Baby,” it’s time for another fully instrumental track. A mix of jazz, klezmer, Eastern melodies, witty Canterbury sounds and rock’n’roll transitions makes for a great cross-section of an album that in no way leaves the listener indifferent. Ziblat once again shows off his lavish multi-instrumental know-how, which still can’t overshadow his ability to compose musical elements into a wonderful whole. The progressive fusion rock adventure is followed by “Buy Me!”, a track with the single potential to reach radio stations. Its intent is expressed already in its length (a good two minutes) and in the title, “Buy Me!”, and its foundation is of course an excellent pop rock song. The lyric is again witty, full of clichés that are once more wrapped in the author’s subtle genius.
“Evolution” is another gem of this album. The roots of Jewish music, klezmer, radiate from it. They’re incredibly worked into the progressive pop rock lines, which at times recall the arrangements of Genesis’s Tony Banks. The two-verse lyric is, as it should be, again clever, silly and witty (“Sitting on their trees; Getting tired of how they’d been; A bunch of chimpanzees; Are evolving self esteem”; dear readers, this really is the beginning of our evolution). Ziblat returns to showing off his guitar compositional and fingerwork skills on “I came, I saw, I left,” where the guitar lines strongly recall the master Hackett. This time, for the first time, I can say with certainty that this is an instrumental progressive rock track, without the usual clowning and playing around with elements of all sorts of musical crafts. The closer is the ballad “The Last Straw,” a kind of meeting between the Beatles and Caravan, between pop rock harmony and Canterbury playfulness.
What can you say after such an incredible journey? Buy this album! Right now, immediately, this second. Modest Midget have exceeded expectations, they’ve surpassed themselves. They’ve made a masterpiece, something the dust won’t settle on anytime soon once it gathers the circle of fans it deserves. “The Great Prophecy of a Small Man,” by the Dutchmen fronted by Israeli-Argentinian Ziblat, simply deserves the title of best debut of the 21st century so far. No two ways about it. And best of all, the musicians leave themselves room to grow. In all these perfect compositions of the most varied instruments and genre elements, with breathtaking vocal interweaving and genius lyrics, Modest Midget can still reach a higher level in their creating. For now we can only hope for something like that, and until then “The Great Prophecy of a Small Man” is a hearty enough morsel, offering with every repeat listen yet another little piece of the unexplored and undiscovered silliness of the witty Modest Midget.
Line-up
Lionel “Lonny” Ziblat – vocals, acoustic/electric/classical guitar, keyboards, bass guitar, percussion
Emiel de Jong – clarinet, soprano/alto/tenor/baritone saxophone, vocals
Bas Wiegers – violin, vocals
Vera van der Bie – cello, double bass
Ilse Eijsink – clarinet
Oene van Geel – viola
The other contributors wish to remain anonymous.
Production
Lionel Ziblat
Tracklist
1. Follow the Noise (0:55)
2. Contemporary Ache (5:17)
3. Troubles in Heaven (3.13)
4. Coffee from Yesterday (2.40)
5. Back from my Trip (3.34)
6. Home seek (4.26)
7. Here I Go (3.22)
8. Baby (3.05)
9. Jorge Knows How Difficult a Musician’s Life Can be, but then Again, Who Doesn’t? (4.00)
10. Buy Me! (2.13)
11. Evolution (3.18)
12. I came, I saw, I left (5.29)
13. The last Straw (5.13)