Vigil in a Wilderness of Mirrors
Author: Peter Podbrežnik
Artist: Fish
Label: EMI Records
Released: 1990
Length: 50:38
Rating: 4.5/5
Scottish vocal oddball Fish (real name Derek William Dick) put out his solo debut not long after parting ways with prog rock legends Marillion. The split came from the constant pressure of sudden fame and the debauched lifestyle that came with it, which by his own admission nearly did him in. Fed up with the ‘rock star’ status, he gathered a bunch of excellent session musicians around him, with guitarist Frank Usher, ex-Dire Straits guitarist Hal Lindes and keyboardist Mickey Simmonds (also known for working with Mike Oldfield, Camel and Renaissance) standing out in particular, and set out to build a solo project that would somehow pry him loose from the massive Marillion legacy. Plenty of people were convinced Fish would simply carry on in the stylistic direction he’d mapped out as a member of the neo prog rock champions, but already on his first solo outing, »Vigil in a Wilderness of Mirrors«, he proved he’d be walking a path that was pretty much entirely his own.
Besides the unique voice and the outsized charisma, one of Fish’s big artistic strengths has always been his knack for writing excellent, introspective, as-deep-as-it-gets lyrics. On »Vigil in a Wilderness of Mirrors« they touch on his inner state after the break with Marillion, patriotism, love troubles and, above all, assorted social-critical themes of the day (the last days of Thatcherism, rampant consumerism, and so on). The Scottish highlander also brought along Mark Wilkinson, Marillion’s longtime cover artist, who designed the covers for all of his early solo projects.
A fairly sizable chunk of the songs on the album took shape in embryonic form even before the farewell to Marillion, which means they were meant for a fifth album with Fish that never came out. The title track, a prog rock classic, boasts an epic, melodramatic chorus of the kind you’d more or less expect from a master of Fish’s caliber. The atmospheric contrast stays at an enviable level throughout, while the upbeat mood keeps growing in intensity. The big patriot also slips in an authentic Scottish arrangement along the way, adding even more color to the vivid rhythmic scheme of this opening evergreen.
The next socially conscious number, a pop rock critique of unbridled capitalism and the ‘dreamland’ on the other side of the Atlantic called »Big Wedge«, has some energetic saxophone mimicry played over synth textures, and it ranks among the top-notch Fish classics. The backing vocal harmonies in the chorus add a generous dose of polish, while the sophisticated piano arrangements add to the fun vibe too.
»State of Mind«, marked by assorted world music motifs and also conceived before the Marillion split, is defined by a thick bassline courtesy of John Giblin. »The Company« is another ambitious cut, seasoned with Scottish patriotism, with an uplifting chorus and folk rock symphonic arrangements that even include the melancholic sound of violins. »A Gentleman’s Excuse Me« is a beautiful, melodramatic, symphonic love ballad where Fish gets a great chance to show off his vivid vocal range. Worth mentioning is that his voice here was already pitched a notch lower than fans were used to from his days with Marillion. By his own account he was practically forced into it if he didn’t want to ‘lose his voice’.
The experimental »The Voyeaur (I Like to Watch)«, a critique of TV voyeurism, has the strongest eighties pulse on the album thanks to the electronic drum rhythm, while the schizophrenic, dark chorus ties neatly into the socially critical lyrics. Of all the songs here, »Family Business« comes closest in vocal delivery to some Marillion classic, while the three-part harmonies between Usher and Lindes conjure up an enviable atmospheric magic. The hard-rocking, symphony-greased hybrid »View from a Hill«, with (then freshly minted) Iron Maiden guitarist Janick Gers guesting, is another interesting experiment, and it gives Fish a nice chance to show off his ‘angry’ side. The closing »Cliche« is an ambitious prog rock treat in the truest sense of the word, soaked from start to finish in a distinctly melancholic atmosphere thanks to weeping slide guitars and grand symphonic curtains in the background.
»Vigil in a Wilderness of Mirrors« is a neo prog rock classic that helped Fish establish himself as a successful solo artist right after the split from Marillion. Sure, it can’t compare with the first four Fish-era Marillion albums, which are a special chapter all their own, but it’s still one of the best solo debuts by a musician who first made a name as a member of an internationally acclaimed band. At the start of his solo journey, plenty of people were convinced Fish would get tangled up in some kind of race with his old band, along the lines of who could put out the more artistically full-blooded and atmospherically richer records, but luckily it didn’t quite go that way, and the Scottish prog rock giant soon made a name for himself as a cult solo musician too.
Line-up
Fish (Derek W. Dick) – vocals
Frank Usher – guitar
Hal Lindes – guitar
John Giblin – bass guitar
Mickey Simmonds – keyboards
GUEST MUSICIANS:
Janick Gers – guitar (8)
Davy Spillane – whistles
Phil Cunningham – whistles, accordion, Bodhrán
Aly Bain – violin (4 and 11)
Gavyn Wright – violin (4)
Alison Jones – violin (12)
Mark Brzezicki – drums
John Keeble – drums (3)
Luis Jardim – percussion (2,3,4 and 9)
Carol Kenyon – backing vocals (2,3,7 and 9)
Tessa Niles – backing vocals (2,7 and 9)
Production
Jon Kelly
Track list
1. Vigil
2. Big Wedge
3. State of Mind
4. The Company
5. A Gentleman’s Excuse Me
6. The Voyeur (I Like To Watch)
7. Family Business
8. View From The Hill
9. Cliché