The Crucible Of Man: Something Wicked pt. 2.

0 12

Artist: Iced Earth
Label: SPV Records
Release: 2008
Runtime: 59:09
Rating: 3.5/5

Whenever Iced Earth drop an album, every metal mountain should tremble! Matt Barlow’s return in the middle of the making of the second part of the Something Wicked saga, “The Crucible Of Man”, was a huge deal. Tim Ripper Owens got the boot overnight, even though he’d left a big mark on both “The Glorius Burden” (2004) and “Framing Armaggedon: Something Wicked Pt. 1” (2007) and we all expected Tim to stay on as lead vocalist for part two as well, which would’ve made sense, since the whole thing is conceptual. But we all know what Barlow means to Schaffer. He’s always the first logical choice, because with Barlow they wrote the songs Iced Earth fans love and cherish most, songs that are slowly picking up the label of cult classics.

So Schaffer had to finish an expansive concept about the showdown of the main character, Seth Abominae, whose mission is to avenge the genocide of the Seth race, settle scores with humanity and gradually bring about its final destruction. In this concept Seth is the antichrist, who right at the start attacks and confronts Jesus Christ head-on, then goes after various influential people in high places of society (rulers), manipulating them so that their weak character traits like greed, rapacity and the like come to the surface. As the final blow to all the civilizations led by these degenerates, there follows, in cascades over two millennia, the (self-)destruction of those civilizations (wars) and the rise of new ones with an equally wretched ending in store. Seth also manipulates God’s intermediaries, testing the weak spots in their character that pull them away from well-meaning Biblical principles, and, contrary to those principles, these people start abusing their position, mistreating and oppressing the human race. For Seth, the people in positions of power are just an extension of his own arm, a tool to carry out his purpose. Ready to wipe out humanity, Seth finally stops, because he sees there’s still hope for humanity’s rebirth, though with a warning that otherwise he can destroy it.

Musically, “The Crucible Of Man” is a tougher Iced Earth morsel to swallow, because it’s cut in a very dark frequency. It shows Jon Schaffer’s growth as an arranger, one who cares about ever fuller sonic layering within the songs, something he began putting into practice very successfully with the Gettysburg trilogy. The fact is that the new album continues down the developmental path of its predecessor in the same spirit. The album is distinctly gloomy. The songs are, practically as a rule, written at a mid-tempo pace and never stray from it. As a rule they differ in the level of aggression only as far as the basic guitar phrase (riff) of each song manages to dictate it in the production. What’s interesting is the feeling that a bit of the “Horror Show” ambience has crept back in on “The Crucible Of Man” in places (e.g. The Revealing). Certainly thanks to Matt Barlow’s vocals, but it’s also important that the classic Iced Earth riff density is once again more prominent in the songs, the kind we know as chopping through “palm-muted” Florida riffing, the classic, instantly recognizable Iced Earth trademark, with a typical example in the song The Dimension Gauntlet. The evil that comes through very effectively at many moments on this record is also reinforced by a nicely done use of Arabic melodic ornaments. The opening Behold The Child is written in curves where it’s hardly difficult to imagine Owens, and the rest of the album doesn’t stray much from that feeling. On the new album the Maiden-style harmony thirds have lain somewhat low, which is welcome for putting the aggression of the riff front and center, so it sounds heavy and doom-laden.

It has to be said that “The Crucible Of Man” may let down anyone who was impatiently waiting for a new “Something Wicked This Way Comes”, “The Dark Saga” or “Burnt Offerings”. Despite the description that the new album effectively puts Iced Earth trademarks front and center, it never reaches the wit, dynamics and variety of ideas of the albums I just mentioned. There isn’t a single fast-paced metal march on the album, so it might bore old Iced Earth fans. The “thankless” realization is interesting: Barlow’s vocals replaced Ripper Owens and practically nothing more than that. The band’s original voice has definitely returned, but the core of the new music is composed in such a way that Ripper would no doubt have fit right into its concept too. What Schaffer gained from swapping Ripper for Barlow on “The Crucible Of Man” is very small, if anything. At least the upside is that Barlow, with much more varied singing, brings the individual acts of the concept album to life more successfully, but because of the considerable monotony the songs are written in, the flaw of him being underused shows. Because of Barlow’s excellent singing, I’m adding half a point to the album, otherwise it deserves no more than three.

Viewed in the light of bringing the chosen cataclysmic concept to life, which is done very nicely on “The Crucible Of Man”, along with the maturity gained over the years and the far fuller production sound of the newer albums, the album will richly reward Iced Earth fans, especially those who also really like both Iced Earth albums with Owens on vocals. On the whole, the album breathes excellent life into the chosen concept. It’s packed with a dramatic, heavy atmosphere of the feeling of the inevitable end of the era of man, which was also Schaffer’s basic intention. You simply have to accept that Schaffer can’t be bothered to rage uncompromisingly anymore (Violate, Stormrider, etc…), and would rather build on atmosphere. That’s the new Iced Earth. And yes. They’re still the definition of quality. Even with “The Crucible Of Man”.

Lineup

Matt Barlow – vocals
Jon Schaffer – guitar, bass guitar, keyboards, lead vocals on track no. 5, backing vocals
Troy Seele – guitar solos on tracks no. 5, 6 and 9
Roy Haynes – bass guitar on tracks no. 3, 5, 6, 10 and 12
Brent Smedley – drums

Production

Jon Schaffer

Tracklist

1. In Sacred Flames
2. Behold The Wicked Child
3. Minions Of The Watch
4. Revealing
5. Gift Or A Curse
6. Crown Of The Fallen
7. Dimension Gauntlet
8. I Walk Alone
9. Harbinger Of Fate
10. Crucify The King
11. Sacrificial Kingdoms
12. Something Wicked
13. Divide And Devour
14. Come What May
15. Epilogue

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.

This website uses cookies to provide online services, advertising systems and functionality that we would not be able to offer without cookies. By visiting and using the website, you consent to the use of cookies. Accept Read more

Privacy & cookies