The Raven That Refused to Sing (And Other Stories)
Author: Peter Podbrežnik
Artist: Wilson, Steven
Label: Kscope
Release: 2013
Running time: 54:03
Rating: 5/5
Steven Wilson, the ultimate workaholic of the progressive rock scene, and, when he’s not busy with his solo career, also the boss of the cult British band Porcupine Tree, a producer and a participant in plenty of interesting side projects, is back with a new solo album. This almost legendary multi-instrumentalist and singer, and a great patron of modern progressive rock who is also a huge fan of old-school prog heritage, has devoted himself entirely to going solo in recent years, shelving his work with Porcupine Tree for the time being. »The Raven That Refused to Sing (And Other Stories)« is the title of his third studio album and the successor to the masterpiece »Grace for Drowning« (2011). On it, Wilson has very successfully joined forces in the production seat with the legendary sound engineer and musician Alan Parsons, who, besides once leading the art rock band The Alan Parsons Project, is also known as the sound engineer on Pink Floyd’s masterpiece »Dark Side of the Moon« (1973) and an important contributor to The Beatles classics »Abbey Road« (1969) and »Let It Be« (1970).
And the list of prestigious guests who helped Mr. Wilson bring this album to life is far from over, which is no surprise, since the Porcupine Tree chief has built up a whole stack of big-name connections in recent years, as you could already hear and see on his previous studio effort. Former Asia guitarist Guthrie Govan steps in as lead guitarist, while Nick Beggs (Kajagoogoo, Steve Hackett) guests on bass, backing vocals and Chapman Stick. Theo Travis, longtime member of Canterbury legends Soft Machine and Gong, lends a hand on woodwinds with flute, saxophone and clarinet. Guitarist and singer Jakko Jakszyk (ex-Level 42, The Tangent, 21st Century Schizoid Band) chips in with backing vocals here and there.
»The Raven That Refused to Sing« first started taking shape during the tour for »Grace for Drowning«, when Wilson went back into the studio and began kneading together new compositions that were originally meant for a future Porcupine Tree album. He later changed his mind and decided he’d rather keep going with his increasingly successful solo career, which stylistically draws plenty of parallels with what Wilson usually creates with Porcupine Tree. Compared to its intensely personal predecessor, which was above all a turbulent, unpredictable ride through different emotional states, »The Raven That Refused to Sing«, which also leans a touch more toward jazz fusion, is a collection of songs telling individual life stories. Wilson’s lyrics, this time ruled by ‘ghosts of the past’, are once again intelligent, nostalgic, pretty deep and insightful, and above all very ‘true to life’, and they often give the listener plenty to think about. The excellent cover art, which is somewhat reminiscent of the Crimson King on the inner sleeve of the legendary King Crimson debut, is really a vivid reflection of the lyrics about the ghosts that dominate »The Raven That Refused to Sing«.
The epic opening treat »Luminol« is a gorgeous hybrid of modern art rock and classic seventies progressive rock, which Wilson, who has worked on reissues of numerous prog classics in recent years, has always held close to his heart. The melancholic yet spirited sound of the electric guitar is unmistakably tied to Steven’s recognizable compositional and instrumental style, while waves of mellotron, crazy hammond organ variations courtesy of Adam Holzman and Travis’s flute keep injecting this turbulent composition with an ‘antique-shop’, at times almost pastoral ambience. The ethereal ambient swells in between, in which Steven’s melodic vocal is nicely backed by hypnotic harmonies, also contain some seriously tasteful symphonic piano arrangements. Dramatic mellotron waves at times recall the golden days of classic King Crimson, one of Wilson’s all-time favorite bands. Marco Minnemann, meanwhile, has a drumming approach that’s pretty similar to the jazzy style of original King Crimson drummer Michael Giles. The lyrics are about a poor street musician who, despite his musical talent, plays on the street from dawn till dusk in all kinds of weather, while passersby have long forgotten that this person even exists, and over time he’s become a kind of ghost, vanishing and reappearing. Like many of Wilson’s lyrics, »Luminol« was partly inspired by a real experience, namely an encounter with a street musician.
»Drive Home« is a melancholic and distinctly ethereal ballad that tells, through its lyrics and in a phantasmagorical way, the story of lost love: one evening the protagonist is driving in his car when he suddenly realizes that his partner, whom he was chatting with only a few minutes earlier, has vanished. Her ghost then reappears and warns the driver that she will ‘always remind him of what happened that night’. The trauma of losing his partner is simply too much, so the protagonist has blocked the unfortunate event out of his memory, as if the woman had never existed. So the words are about a female ghost and a tragic car crash, which fits perfectly with the sorrowful atmosphere, in the midst of which Wilson’s vocal, especially during the symphonically arranged chorus, once again does a great job as a subtle storyteller. Individual acoustic-orchestral arrangements help build the shattering mood, while Govan’s closing guitar solo is a real balm for body and soul.
On »The Holy Drinker«, symphonic prog rock, prog metal and jazz fusion blend together very successfully. It’s an extremely complex piece whose lyrics revolve around hypocrisy, above all the everyday sanctimony of fake moralists led by priests and politicians who keep ‘lecturing’ ordinary people instead of first cleaning up their own backyard. Travis especially impresses here with wild clarinet improvisations, while the ‘metal’ guitar passages bring the necessary rage and edge, radiating from the helplessness of seeing our society ruled by hypocritical crooks of every kind. The brutal guitar passages build massive walls of sound with layered harmonies, while the rhythm section successfully moves between jazzy and metal rhythmic nuances. Wilson’s vocal approach this time is also thoroughly dramatized and angry, which isn’t exactly typical for him. The keyboard textures, led by mellotron and piano, are once again as colorful as it gets and contain plenty of witty improvisational flourishes. The same goes for Travis’s flute solo experiments and the gritty layer of hammond organ that bursts with full force through the individual frenzied rhythms. After a brief lull in the last part of the composition comes a brutal and completely uncompromising instrumental finale.
»The Pin Drop« also has phantasmagorical lyrics and atmosphere, this time grappling with the, sadly, all-too-relevant problem of an empty relationship in which someone stays only for the sense of security and social approval. Here the culprit is a man who killed his partner and got rid of her body in a river, while now her ghost speaks to him from the beyond amid his madness. It’s another distinctly complex masterpiece full of ambient nuances, where the mood practically never stops shifting in line with the many time changes and ethereal multi-voice choruses. Overall, the atmosphere keeps swinging between nostalgia and anxiety. Travis’s saxophone improvisations bring jazz-fusion experimentalism, while the guitar passages are as ruffled as they come and fit perfectly with the rich mellotron waves. The pastoral middle section, with its ‘Victorian’ feel, is somewhat reminiscent of classic Genesis, while the guitar lines and ethereal vocal harmonies are completely their own thing and come closest to the usual Porcupine Tree sound.
»The Watchmaker«, yet another ghost story, opens with a gentle intro played on acoustic guitar that fits Wilson’s strongly melancholic voice perfectly. This time the lyrics are about an old watchmaker for whom his work meant everything, and who, unable to show emotion, totally neglected his wife, with whom he’d lived for more than fifty years. In truth he never loved her and treated her merely as a necessary appendage. In the end, when she’d really gotten on his nerves, he killed her and hid her body in the cellar under his workshop. But after fifty years together, his wife isn’t about to leave him just like that, so after a while her ghost returns from the beyond and takes the hellish watchmaker with her. Here too, both in the lyrics and in the acoustic intro, you could talk about certain ambient parallels with classic Genesis and King Crimson, who were especially fond of this kind of phantasmagorical tale in the early seventies (say, the songs »The Musical Box« and »The Letters«). The pastoral intro is followed by an orchestrally arranged instrumental section laced with flute passages, in the middle of which Govan shines above all with wild guitar improvisations, though his virtuoso comrades give him serious competition. Melodramatic piano touches and ethereal harmonies successfully crank up the tense, mysterious and anxious mood, which means Mr. Wilson and his buddies reach a new level of arranging brilliance. The closing section, where Nick Beggs especially shines with his rattling bass lines, is a pure jazz fusion freak-out and a build-up of an ever creepier mood as the wife’s ghost returns from the beyond to settle accounts with her ‘dear’ husband.
The album closes with the title track, »The Raven That Refused to Sing«, yet another epic masterpiece with lyrics about ghosts. Compared to the other lyrics on the album, these are distinctly contemplative and even leave a hopeful ray of light at the end. Once again the main character is an old man, but this time a positive one. This old fellow is a real nostalgic who keeps drifting back in his thoughts to his childhood, when he spent the best days of his life. Back then he played with his sister, who meant the most to him in life and who died very young. After her death, his life became spiritually miserable and empty. One day, the old man suddenly spots a mysterious raven in his garden and recognizes it as the physical manifestation of his own sister’s ghost, returned from the beyond after many long years. He becomes convinced that if he can somehow teach the raven to sing, he’ll hear his sister’s voice again, and the two of them will be able to fly off together into the beyond. Fittingly, the atmosphere of this lyrically deep song is distinctly melancholic, but over time, after a successful build-up on fragile piano, somewhat more optimistic and bright, almost epic orchestral nuances begin to take over, led by flute and mellotron. Wilson’s vocal, with its distinctly contemplative nature, once again has the wonderful ability to shake even a potentially hard-hearted listener and awaken in them plenty of almost forgotten higher emotions.
»The Raven That Refused to Sing (And Other Stories)« is Wilson’s best solo album to date and yet another entry in an unbroken run of modern progressive rock masterpieces, once again confirming this versatile musician and producer as the reigning hero of experimental rock. You simply can’t praise this multilayered work enough, with its brilliant musical content and phenomenal production that deserves a deep bow, and it’s almost certain it will soon rank among the greatest classics in the history of progressive rock. Early in the year, »The Raven That Refused to Sing« is already the top contender for best progressive rock album of 2013. Steven faces a seriously tough task ahead of keeping up and continuing his incredibly successful string of studio masterpieces that set new standards for modern prog rock, but from a master like that you can always expect surprises of the best kind.
Lineup
Steven Wilson – vocals, mellotron, keyboards, guitar, bass guitar on “The Holy Drinker”
Guthrie Govan – lead guitar
Nick Beggs – bass guitar, Cheapman stick on “The Holy Drinker”, backing vocals
Adam Holzman – keyboards, hammond organ, piano, minimoog
Marco Minnemann – drums, percussion
Theo Travis – flute, saxophone, clarinet
GUEST MUSICIANS:
Jakko Jakszyk – backing vocals on “Luminol” and “The Watchmaker”
Alan Parsons – guitar solo on “The Holy Drinker”
orchestral arrangements by Dave Stewart, performed by the London Session Orchestra
Production
Steven Wilson and Alan Parsons
Track list
1. Luminol
2. Drive Home
3. The Holy Drinker
4. The Pin Drop
5. The Watchmaker
6. The Raven That Refused to Sing